Health: What’s Up with the Gluten-Free Diet?

Health: What’s Up with the Gluten-Free Diet?

The Twitterverse is yammering about Miley Cyrus…again. This time it’s about how skinny she is. Some are saying she has an eating disorder, to which she quickly fires back: “For everyone calling me anorexic I have a gluten and lactose allergy. It’s not about weight it’s about health. Gluten is crapppp anyway!”

Is it?

Author : Christelyn Karazin

Author's Website | Articles from

The Twitterverse is yammering about Miley Cyrus…again. This time it’s about how skinny she is. Some are saying she has an eating disorder, to which she quickly fires back: “For everyone calling me anorexic I have a gluten and lactose allergy. It’s not about weight it’s about health. Gluten is crapppp anyway!”

Is gluten really crap? Lately it’s been blamed for all kinds of ailments, from irritable bowel syndrome to autism. “There’s absolutely no evidence that a gluten-free diet promotes weight loss,” Karen Ansel, a registered dietitian and spokeswoman for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. “However, there is data that indicates that following a gluten-free diet can result in a diet that’s low in key nutrients — especially iron, zinc and B vitamins such as folate and niacin.”

In fact, eating too many processed gluten free foods can make you put on a few pounds. Rachel Begun, a registered dietitian living with celiac disease and food industry consultant, says, “People who go gluten-free may gain weight if they rely mostly on highly-processed gluten free foods, many of which tend to be higher in fat, calories and sugar than their gluten-containing counterparts.” Ansel agrees, and adds, “Gluten-free foods also tend to lack fiber that fills us up and can help us manage our weight.” [SOURCE]

So what gives? I’m all for cutting out the sugar–there’s clear evidence for that. But gluten, too? Lemme just go outside and eat some grass like the dogs do.

Be Sociable! Share!
Pinterest


Related Posts


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
SheThrives11 314 pts

I also have a gluten allergy. I've been advised by my doctor not to eat more than 8 oz of bread, flour, pasta, etc. a day.  When I do eat more than I'm supposed to, I experience an increase in energy followed by what I call "the fall": breaking out into hives, becoming agitated, not being able to sleep at night, increase in oil on my face, etc.  The worst part about my allergy is after eating anything with gluten, I immediately become bloated in my mid-section, which is publicly embarrassing. The good thing is that my weight is finally regulated with exercise.

Shulamit 1982 pts

For info on detoxing go to : http://www.evolvingwell.com/TopDetoxingTips.pdf 

and for information on the lifestyle gor over to here: http://www.glutenfreeschool.com/

eugeniaberg 7245 pts moderator

I know alot of ppl who have gluten allergies and a bunch who are lactose intolerant. My old nurse, who was a nutritionist too and Jewish told me once and I've heard this before that cow's milk is really not human consumption and I had a professor of physical anthropology say about 80% of the world's population is lactose intolerant if you're Northern European it's all good but most other ppl have issues with cow's milk. As a person who is experiencing some serious digestion issues from having type 1 diabetes for so long and it just happens, damage to nerves which are in your stomach too. If you have digestion issues there is tons of stuff you have to stay away from. I have slow digestion which may turn into what's called gastroparesis which many, many long time type 1 diabetics have, I also have swelling in my intestines. So I can't eat sinewy meat, greasy food, spicy food or raw vegetables. It just depends on who the person is, that's why it's not always a good idea to take your clues about eating from some fad. You need to know how YOUR digestive system works and probably get a nutritionist. I don't know if they're covered on most insurance but since I'm a diabetic it's covered for me. 

Karla00 382 pts

Aside from my seasonal and everyday allergies I'm also lactose intolerant and I've developed a sensitivity to gluten. I also have something called "exercise induced allergies". Why? I don't know but I've been living like this for the past 8 years. After making the decision to start the allergy shots 8 years ago my Allergist suggested that I have a consultation with a Nutritionist and look into modifying my diet. I don't use dairy products "except yogurt" the live and active cultures prevents it from causing cramps. I also stay away from most foods that contain gluten. With that said, I would also like to add that weight loss can be rapid on a gluten free diet only if you stay away from the processed gluten free foods. Like Miley I don't eat gluten free foods that are processed, they are high in fat and carbs and they taste "yucky"! My diet consists of some soy, fish, veggies and fruit. My allergies have greatly improved and I feel so much better with this lifestyle change. The weight loss was just an added benefit. It's sad that some individuals are seeing this diet as a fad; when for most of us living with celiac disease and or allergies it's a way of life!

Karla 18226 pts

I don't have a gluten allergy nor am I lactose-intolerant but I rarely drink cow's milk because I don't like the aftertaste.  I'm hooked on coconut milk by So Good for my muesli or smoothies.  During my 40 days of non-processed foods, I did find this recipe, mainly because I had made mayonnaise from scratch and needed to do something with the egg whites.  It's gluten-free and delish!  http://www.marthastewart.com/314011/flourless-double-chocolate-pecan-cookies

JoDee 7 pts

Nevermind Miley Cyrus making this a popular thing; this anti gluten/dairy/soy diet has been around for years for people with moderate to severe allergies. 

 

 It took me some time to accept it, but I realized I had issues in college when I started developing an allergy to beer and other alcohol (so, so sad, I was). Literally, one sip of the wrong beer makes me look like a blowfish. Because I didn't have this reaction to any foods at the time, I didn't know what the heck was going on with me.

 

My PCP and acupuncturist recommended that I go on this  gluten/dairy/soy-free diet late last year. It's very hard to stick with this diet, especially if you do not have the funds to purchase some of the alternative foods available. I gave it a try and lasted about a week, but during that week I did experience some radical differences in the way that I felt. I'm someone who is always sick due to poor diet choices (I own up to that) and I am now trying to make changes. Will this diet be my miracle worker? Meh. We'll see!

 

I haven't completely cut out gluten, dairy or soy from my diet yet (I'm a poor college student -- I have to survive on SOMETHING), but I do hope to be able to successfully transition to a modified version of this diet one day and meet my health goals. And to find a good-tasting, gluten-free beer would be nice. 

 

Law Wanxi 5789 pts

Wow, I don't know what to say.  Destiny Hope "Miley" Cyrus has, without the benefit of dietician or nutritionist training, become an expert on what to eat.  I guess it's time for me to start my line of women's fashion wear or open a basketball summer camp.  After all, I kind of vaguely resemble Vivienne Tam or Jeremy Lin, who should marry Jennifer Lopez so that it can be J-Lin and J-Lo.  Besides, I think it's his turn.  

 

This year's fat-free is gluten-free.  Back some 30-odd [very odd] years ago, I didn't know a single child in my school who had food issues.  Now they all do, every child I encounter can't eat something fairly ordinary.  And that's just the children; adults are now so restricted that catering a simple intimate buffet/dinner for 150 has become a total nightmare.  Since Southern California leads the nation in cool, let me give you a glimpse of the latest in entertaining; BYOF.  Bring Your Own Food; you heard it here first.  Even endless platters of organic local-sourced raw vegetables aren't raw-y and vegetable-y enough for LA.  

 

As an experiment here in Orange County, I've started telling people they can't give my grandmother's dog, Sparkle, any form of the treats they have for their own dogs because he's allergic to peanuts and chicken.  BTW, he's not.  That was fun for a few months, so now I've added gluten-free to the list.  Everyone accepts this as some kind of totally serious matter and a few have commented that they should check it out with their vet!  Not one single person has pointed out to me that a dog's favourite snack is cat poop and that their favourite buffet line is a tipped over garbage can behind a restaurant.  Not one.  I'm thinking of adding 'nitrogen in the air' to the list, but I fear the advent of helicopter parents requiring schools to ventilate classrooms with heli-ox or pure O2 or fitting their kids with diving rebreathers.  It'll happen soon enough without my input.

 

I realize that there are people with genuine food allergies, but it's getting out of hand.  It's almost like if you or your kid can eat anything, then you're some kind of unrefined, unsophisticated lower-life form best shunned by polite society.  

Shulamit 1982 pts

 Law Wanxi a lot of it is because of all the synthetic stuff they are putting into the food. but me i was diagnosed with a milk allergy when i was 2 weeks old. i literally fainted. as i got older i developed skin issues then later certain vitamin deficiencies associated with celiac's. i also think a lot of the allergies were misdiagnosed. its common.

Law Wanxi 5789 pts

 Shulamit 

It's not that common.  You're an exception.  You were diagnosed, probably through dietary input exclusion, properly at 2 weeks of age.  I'm fairly certain that, at 14 days, you didn't read an article in the esteemed peer-reviewed medical journal 'Cosmopolitan' or the equally valid 'Elle' about lactose intolerance and decide, without the evidence-based protocols you had when you were a newborn, that you were lactose-intolerant.  You're the real thing.  

Shulamit 1982 pts

 Law Wanxi Tis true however I did read a lot of health journals and information with the help of a few naturalist friends i was able to diagnose my gluten allergy which the doctor later confirmed. Then again I am smart as a whip, I was in the medical field ten years I was able to diagnose things even when the doctors couldn't. Don't discount self evaluation. Many times it saves the person's life. As for Elle and Cosmo, umm yeah. never read them.

Shulamit 1982 pts

 Law Wanxi and I am a stylist, image consultant, fashion blogger, go figure

Brenda55 19416 pts moderator

 Law Wanxi  ROTFLMAO!!!!!!!!!  Law I do not care if Sirloin sees this.  I am totally in love with you. {Wiping tears from eyes}

SirLoinDeBeef 2496 pts

 Brenda55 If you're interested in tDCS, I wouldn't mind sharing information.

Karla 18226 pts

 Law Wanxi Love this so much, I'm printing it out for future reference.  I'd like to be able to quote you verbatim.

SirLoinDeBeef 2496 pts

 Law Wanxi ROTFLMAO - back 50 years ago, eating at a Chinese restaurant and using chopsticks was sorta/kinda Pinko-Communistic - couldn't even date a black or Asian girl - defacto segregation - it 'just wasn't done' - a cause for being Disowned-And-Disinherited, a distressingly common theme in my ultraconservative-San-Diego-California-in-the-50s upbringing.

BTW, Law, on an off-topic comment - I was surfing on a wilderness survival thread, and observed that, ont in camp, the narrator used chopsticks to fish live coals out of a fire, plopping them into his Swiss Volcano Stove - am I forgiven?

SirLoinDeBeef 2496 pts

 Law Wanxi Then, after the BYOF dinner, there comes the delicate matter of thye upset stomach and intestinal troubles - this being Southern California and the Space Age, might I suggest a dose of the INTERGALATIC LAXITIVE ...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=SExx1LqgNZM

The Working Home Keeper 6592 pts

 Law Wanxi "Back some 30-odd [very odd] years ago, I didn't know a single child in my school who had food issues.  Now they all do, every child I encounter can't eat something fairly ordinary."

 

Having elementary school aged children, I encounter this every year.  It seems like in every class, there is at least one kid (or several) who have some type of allergy.  When I was a kid, food allergies were practically unheard of.  I can't remember anyone in my entire elementary school (which was K-8) that had an allergy. 

Karla 18226 pts

 The Working Home Keeper  Law Wanxi My BFF and I were just talking about this because our church asked us to provide snacks for the upcoming Vacation Bible School.  The list of "don'ts" was so long... no nuts, gluten, milk, peanut butter, cheese, etc.  Our church also provides an allergy-free Host for communion because of all the children who have food allergies in our congregation.  Back in the day, my mom, who is and has been lactose-intolerant her entire life, was considered a freak.  Nowadays, she can even drink milk if she wants to.

Islandgirl 505 pts

 The Working Home Keeper I've read that the problem is that today's children and the environment that they are kept in are way too clean. This in turn causes their immune system not to develop  as it should hence all the allergies. Another theory floating around that it is that parents are unnecessarily eliminating certain foods from their children's diet as a result of misreporting of scientific studies in the media. Personally I hate it when people say that they are allergic to something when in actuality they just dislike it. It makes life hell for people like me who have real allergies like be taken seriously. I've had people lie to me saying that the food they are supplying are nut free to try to test if I was telling the truth. Some pretty unpleasant trips to the hospitals have resulted in the past as result of those actions.    

The Working Home Keeper 6592 pts

 Islandgirl That's terrible Islandgirl!  I never disbelieve any of the parents who say their children have allergies.  If it was my child, I would certainly want the other parents and teachers to take it seriously.  Most parents do and follow the school's guideline of only sending in nut free snacks and store bought items which have the ingredients listed.

 

We've never limited foods with our children - with the exception of no honey before age 1yo.  And while cleanliness and hygiene are important, I don't bathe my kids in sanitizer!  Thankfully, we haven't had to deal with allergies.  My clever little 9yo has tried to convince me on many occasions that she's allergic to onions.  Momma's not buying it LOL!    

ChristieRJohnson 1104 pts

 Islandgirl Are you kidding me???  Doing stuff like that can kill somebody.....I hope you gave them a piece of your mind and a foot up the backside, once you got out of the hospital.

I do agree that people are too worried about germs.  Germs help your immune system.  It's like weight lifting, you break down in hopes that when it rebuilds, it will be stronger.  Does that mean don't bathe or brush your teeth? No.  But taking antibiotics for a cold is just a waste.  When you have a cold, you cough, the body is trying to fight it off.  It may be unpleasant to hear and be around, but the body is doing what it is meant to do.

Islandgirl 505 pts

 ChristieRJohnson Once I got out of the hospital everything resolved itself as it should. I stopped talking to the idiots who played the dangerous stunts. I now don't eat out very much to avoid such situations. I do miss the ability to eat nutella though :s

AleeL 440 pts

Gluten-free will usually only cause you to gain weight if you replace the gluten-containing foods with gluten-free substitutes. Otherwise, it can cause a person to lose weight because of the resulting lack in sugar, wheat, and processed foods. My diet is gluten-free.

 

Gluten-free definitely doesn't mean lacking in zinc, b-vitamins or iron. Meat and eggs, two gluten-free foods have tons of those so you're probably getting more than the recommended amount of those, except maybe thiamin which you can get from beans.

 

That said, clearly Miley just lost weight because she was called "fat" by some morons on Twitter. It took about three nanoseconds for her to drop 15 pounds after that incident, even though at first she claimed to "love" her thicker body. I think her body now is fine however -- she is not too thin.

Brandon Christian 82 pts

I think you're going a little extreme here and you're including what I think we should be against anyways, which is that most of our food now is overly processed. At it's base you are avoiding Wheat, Barley and Rye. You need iron? Eat beans. B vitamins actually are found in unprocessed foods, the processing of food destroys the amount of B vitamins. You again get B vitamins from beans, but there's also peppers, bananas, potatoes, fish, shellfish, meat and poultry. Zinc as well is found in beans, nuts, seeds, beef, lamb, and lobster. Yes, whole grains are sources for these three things, and yes our American diet is lacking of these things unless they are processed. Yet, I ate mostly a diet of beans, potatoes and greens and got all the daily recommended intake of vitamins.

My latest conversation: Help make Brandon Christison's first album

Shulamit 1982 pts

 Above Ground Pools I agree! If you eat fresh fruit and veggies, nuts, and beans you will get your daily intake of all that you need..

Brandon Christian 82 pts

 Shulamit It's amazing how many of the vitamins and minerals we need are found in beans alone. But for vitamin A and C you need to include at minimum some greens and potatoes. I've become a fan of dandelion greens, I think they taste really good with potatoes. Sweet potatoes, diced small, actually cook in a pan in about 5 minutes, I just throw in some spinach and dandelion greens and have a quick little hash. Red potatoes and white potatoes tend to take a minimum of 15 minutes to prepare. I find it interesting the concept of eating for your nationality and there's a recent trendy diet called the primal diet which is about eating whole foods, and not eating grains, but interestingly enough also excludes beans. I, myself, am a mutt (japanese, mexican, irish, scottish, english). Eating for my ancestry would be complicated.

My latest conversation: Help make Brandon Christison's first album

Shulamit 1982 pts

 Above Ground Pools Good lawd and I thought my Irish, Black, Native American and Spanish was a mess but those peoples tend to have similar diets and I am 80% african ancestry so I am good. Beans is a staple in an black diet or it should be. My green of choice is Kale. I absolutely love it. High in Iron, Fiber and Vit B. Its fabulous.. I also love brocolli and mustard greens. Choctah is fabulous as well. I have been eating pretty good for two months and I am about to up my game..I want this lifestyle choice to stick. I have lost 15lbs already and I am already less bloated looking. I actually told my doctor I had celiacs because of some seriously high symptoms and was recently tested. so here goes nothing.

Brandon Christian 82 pts

 Shulamit I actually almost bought Kale the other day. I've never tried it. I'm actually a pretty even mix 1/4 Japanese, 1/4 Scottish, 1/4 Mexican, 1/8 English, 1/8 Irish. I'm glad this diet is working for you. I've been hearing a lot about the school systems and their idea of a healthy diet and that some are taking away kids lunches and making them eat theirs because they don't feel like they're eating correctly, but that it's not necessarily being used for kids bringing candy bars and such, but kids who have a more vegetarian lunch or something like that. It's interesting how the government is wanting to police what we eat.

My latest conversation: Help make Brandon Christison's first album

sparel 903 pts

 Shulamit So true even though I'm not really a bean girl but fresh fruits and vegetable is the way to go

AleeL 440 pts

 Above Ground Pools 

 

You read my mind -- posted what I did.

 

Are you gluten-free? :)

Brandon Christian 82 pts

 AleeL  I actually am not gluten-free, but I ate a gluten-free diet for Lent because I decided to eat a kinda 3rd world diet of just staple foods: beans, rice, potatoes and corn. I logged my diet to see how many vitamins, protein, calories, carbs, etc. I was eating. I ended up having to add some greens into the diet so I could eat the recommended Vitamin A and C intake, but found that with this extremely restrictive gluten-free diet I was able to get the nutrition I needed.

My latest conversation: Help make Brandon Christison's first album

TanishaShulamitEverett 74 pts

Well for some its a fad for me its a must lifestyle. And Ciley is right, usually gluten allergies are in conjunction with lactose allergies. About 45% of black Americans suffer from this disorder and it can cause a myriad of symptoms and diseases such as chronic candida, excessive weight gain, bloating, irritable bowel, diabetes, Vit B and D deficiency, iron deficiency, rash and eczema to name a few. It is becoming an epidemic in our society as a whole and many times what we think is a elevated sugar issue or diabetes is actually us being allergic to gluten and wheat. These things are not natural to our homeland so our body does not respond well to it. I am insisting that black ppl or anyone for that matter be checked for Celiac's before accepting a diagnosis of Diabetes and other disorders. You can add beans and kale (fiber and iron) and make your own bread from Almond or Corn Flour like I do. Its much healthier anyways. Another expert on the matter is over at

http://www.evolvingwell.com. Her name is Jennifer Fugo. you can contact her for more info.

Christelyn 8739 pts moderator

 TanishaShulamitEverett The a good point. I've heard this too. I'm really interested in the concept of eating for your ancestry.

Shulamit 1982 pts

 Christelyn  I've been doing a lot of research about it. For instance, pork is not native to Africa and nor are cows. But goats and fowl are so it is best to stick with those meat /milk sources. I eat goat cheese and drink almond mild. Sweet Potatoes/Yams are native to Africa so I refrain from eating white potatoes as much as possible --I have a thing for french fries-- And I am learning to eat veggies and fruits when they are in season to steer clear of preservatives and pesticides

dasdbobb 1380 pts

@Christelyn @TanishaShulamitEverett I'm Swedish and german. does thay mean i have to live on swedish meatballs and wienerschnitzel?

Shulamit 1982 pts

 dasdbobb  Christelyn  TanishaShulamitEverett oh dear.. lol..have fun with that :-)

Brenda55 19416 pts moderator

 dasdbobb  Christelyn  TanishaShulamitEverett 

 

OMG the visuals.

SirLoinDeBeef 2496 pts

 Christelyn Ah, eating for my ancestry.  A noble concept.  A significant part of my ancestry is Celtic (Scots-Irish) and Native-American, so it looks like it's corn, beans and squash for me ... plus oatmeal, beef, mutton and haggis (well, scrapple) ... plus rabbit, deer, shellfish & dog ... plus plenty of beer & whiskey.

Christelyn 8739 pts moderator

 SirLoinDeBeef AHAHAHAHAHA! mmm. Beer. Tried whiskey recently---whew! Can't do it, cap'n.

SirLoinDeBeef 2496 pts

 Christelyn Ah, whiskey - DIY - start with a liter of EverClear (95% proof) - dump it into a container with a screw-top lid - fill the empty bottle with water and pour it in, too (cuts it 50%).

Get an old OAK stair tread - wash it well - shave off a couple of handfuls of scrapings with a plane - put these in a glass/wood bowl and set it on fire (dryer lint works real well) - when about half burnt, clap on a cover - fire goes out - when cool, take two handfuls and plop them into the container - screw on the lid - put it aside for 4 weeks (slosh it now and then).

After a month, pour the glop into an old t-shirt over a bowl - squeeze out the liquid - throw out the t-shirt - then take the brown liquid and pour it into a couple of glass liter bottles, with a coffee filter in the funnel.

Let it sit for a while ... now you've got whiskey.

And here ya think men couldn't do food ...

Remind me to tell ya how to do 'popcorn' chicken!