Jeremy Lin and the Myth of Black Athletic Superiority

Jeremy Lin and the Myth of Black Athletic Superiority

There seems to be something a bit more sinister coming from Lin’s male African-American detractors, something that hints at a fear that if non-blacks were to begin dominated the NBA, the myth of black male athletic superiority might be challenged. And if black males are not naturally athletic, then what exactly are black men ‘naturally’ good at doing? If the myth of superior black athleticism goes out the window, then what will be left to maintain the black male mystique?

Author : Jamila Akil

Author's Website | Articles from

Jeremy Lin, a graduate of Harvard University with a major in Economics and former basketball for the Crimson, is now playing for the New York Knicks as a guard. If you haven’t heard about Lin yet, you must not pay close attention to men’s professional basketball. Lin’s rise has been nothing short of meteoric. Lin went from not being picked up in the 2010 NBA draft, to playing on a couple of teams I’ve never even heard of, to playing for the Golden State Warriors (an NBA team to be sure, but still…), to now playing for the New York Knicks where he was instrumental in a win over the powerhouse LA Lakers. Who is this guy? Lin’s story is the stuff sports dreams are made of. But of course, with all the excitement and hype Lin was bound to arouse the ire of a couple of ‘haters’.

Both blacks and Asians have been the victims of the pernicious stereotypes–black people are supposedly more athletic than other groups while Asians are all super-duper smart, they’re “model minorities”. Less than two months ago I sat in a class where the professor of my management class thought it would be funny to play off some well-worn stereotypes for a few kicks and giggles. According to my professor, last semester an Asian girl has earned more that the required points to get an A in the class and “if an Asian girl can do it, you all can do it too.” In another class shortly thereafter, this same professor showed a picture of four people dressed in business attire crossing the finish line of a race; two of the business-clothing clad people were white men, who were crossing the finish line first, followed by a whit woman with a black male bringing up the rear. My professor said that he was surprised that photo didn’t have the woman winning the race, and “oh, look at this, a black guy bringing up the rear, you know how fast they are…” Yes, in 2012 I was subjected to these jokes in an auditorium full of colleges students, some of whom laughed while others looked like they just didn’t know how to respond.

So it doesn’t surprise me in the least that Lin acknowledges that he has been subject to jokes about his race. ESPN.com fired a staffer who published a headline with a derogatory epithet that has been used to refer to people of Asian descent.

What is worst of all is that some of the most racially insensitive remarks made about Lin have come from famous African-American males, who one would think would know better considering how they themselves has surely been subject to racist stereotypes. On twitter producer/director Spike Lee referred to Lin as follows: Jeremy “Kung Fu Hustle” Lin; Jeremy “Hidden Dragon”Lin; and, Jeremy “Crouching Tiger” Lin. Boxer Floyd Mayweather, Jr., tweeted, “Jeremy Lin is a good player but all the hype is because he’s Asian.” To an extent, what Mayweather says is true. Asian players have been a rarity in the NBA, but the rarity of Asian players in basketball shouldn’t detract from the fact that Lin seems to be a genuinely good player–look at his stats, watch Lin play–with a tremendous amount of potential for a long and successful career.

There seems to be something a bit more sinister coming from Lin’s male African-American detractors, something that hints at a fear that if non-blacks were to begin dominated the NBA, the myth of black male athletic superiority might be challenged. And if black males are not naturally athletic, then what exactly are black men ‘naturally’ good at doing? If the myth of superior black athleticism goes out the window, then what will be left to maintain the black male mystique?

I expect Lin’s rise in the NBA to break down stereotypes that would claim Asians are star academicians but that it should be surprising if Asians are also star athletes. And if the edifice of the stereotype of black men being naturally athletic also comes crashing down, which would in turn lead to an acknowledgement that blacks are good at a whole host of activities that don’t involve athleticism, well…that would be a good thing too. Now is as good a time as any to stop stereotyping an entire racial/ethnic group of people.

Be Sociable! Share!
Pinterest


Related Posts


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
josie3144 128 pts

He has a unauthorized ice cream named Lin Sanity that use to have fortune cookie pieces...and now it has waffle pieces...the nerve of BEN & JERRY ICE CREAM...please people want respect but they don't give it...Lin's camp confirmed he applies to trademark Linsanity....there are 3 people that put in to trademark Linsanity too...and a guy already bought the website Linsanity.com...please people...let the man make money if he chooses not to profit from it..then go wild....free enterprise you got to love it...

Blackberry 1177 pts

@josie3144 As a person who works in the intellectual property field I could not agree with your more Josie. Lin is going to win these fights in court, but now he's gotta spend his money (which as this point is not much) stopping people from infringing on his right of publicity. I'm sure his players contract already allots the team rights to his intellectual property (at least with regards to basketball). Hopefully team and league lawyers will get involved to stop the leeches.

Shulamit 1982 pts

I caught this dude playing the other day--I am a soccer girl-- and I was like GO ASIAN DUDE GO!! Like seriously dude can shoot some hoops unlike Houston's own Yao Ming who can only block.. We need to see faces like this in sports.. seriously..

Ricky T 481 pts

Shulamit Yeah Yao just dunks in people faces all day and then block shots. As we progress and social economics change, we will see faces like Lin in the future. Its just a matter of time. History repeats itself for all the newcomer ethnic groups. The older generations fought through color barriers (jackie robinson..etc), unfortunately, we didn't learn our lessons and our current generation also has to fight through color barriers...and future ones will probably do as well ( middle eastern groups...etc) Oh well, such is life in these United States.

Blackberry 1177 pts

I saw the racist ESPN headline and my jaw dropped! When I first heard there was a slur I couldn't even think of what the slur could be....thats how unfathomable this was to me. Then I saw the headline and just...

I can recall being really little and seeing racist cartoons with hispanic/black/Asian stereotypes being played out.....but I honestly thought we'd moved on overtly racist headlines.

Ricky T 481 pts

Also, Jeremy Lin is the Jackie Robinson of baseball. You need a first to break through the barriers and a whole wave will follow. History repeats itself. I hope more kids the black community will also break into more meaningful situations instead of watching media hype up singers and athletes that really does not help the kids any.

Law Wanxi 5805 pts

Ricky T

"Jeremy Lin is the Jackie Robinson of baseball."

Uh, actually, Jackie Robinson is the Jackie Robinson of baseball."

And this guy ain't no Jackie Robinson, either.

1. J-Lin didn't have to wait for the basketball equivalent of Kenesaw Mountain Landis to die so that the basketball equivalent of Branch Rickey could get him into the NBA development league, the basketball equivalent of the minor leagues, specifically the Montreal Royals of 1946.

2. J-Lin hasn't had to stay in segregated hotels.

3. J-Lin didn't endure being a commissioned officer in the Army, only to be referred to as "That N****r Lieutenant" by his own superior officers and nearly every White MP [and they were all White] he encountered.

I could go on and on and on about the differences between the two, but I have to get back to work. Let's just let it go as a supremely bad comparison.

Ricky T 481 pts

Again, Freakonomics. Asian parents don't go about raising their children with sports the same way America does. Back in the 50s/60s, certain countries are still 3rd world and the chances of a stable engineering, doctor, law job is more than 50%. Professional athlete is like what 0.0000001%? Parents want the best for their kids. As the situation gets better, more and more people ( regardless of color ) can take that risk of pushing their kids towards sports, music, and entertainment industries. Hence, OF COURSE, you're not going to see a lot of Asians in the sports, music, or entertainment business.

In similar ways, I think the black community should go for more balance and not let images of black entertainers and athletes skew on what they SHOULD or SHOULD NOT do. I see too many kids think they will be singers or athletes. There are only so many slots out there to fill and millions to fill it. While a professional positions have much more need.

VintageNarcissa 3151 pts

All I have to say is haters gonna hate. It's not like it hasn't been becoming more apparent that there are many athletically able Asians. Hello, Yao Ming! People need to stop riding on the coat tails of black athletes and realize that the average black dude is exactly that, average.

josie3144 128 pts

I just love ChilLin's great attitude...its all about we not me...I will give the overly exposed NBA players a pass for saying silly things..but Mayweather...be quiet..and get in the ring with Pac Man...that mess that the ESPN's former employee put on the website...that was a stroke of genius..all the racist need to be outed...

I almost fell out of the bed when I saw that people started spreading rumors that Kim K was dating him..GIVE ME A BREAK....she probably started that rumor.....GO LINtastic

Bellydancer 789 pts

I am not feeling sorry for black athletes who continue to do crazy shit off and on the court.

The baby mama drama, crazy ghetto friends/family, reality shows, drug abuse, wasting millions of dollars, tax problems, gun fights, fist fights, bar fights(they like to fight) and all the other mess that black athletes seem to get drawn into. It's no wonder that recruiters are looking elsewhere for talent.

It reminds me of pictures, that some bm bloggers when they are trying to getin digs at bw, like to post when they show a white girl with black features ex. big booty, thick lips and thighs etc... it always says underneath the picture "all this and no attitude" well I guess that's what asian and other non black athletes will be placed under when they replace bm.

kiki100 630 pts

Hmmm Mayweather comes to mind for about 4 of those categories...Shame. I am so team Paquio and am proud of Lin.

blackwomanalive 373 pts

Bellydancer I agree. Can someone please explain to me why the heck DBR's think they have the right to go on and on about a BW's attitude.......but nobody EVER checks them on arrogance? This is a huge problem and what I have come to find out is that by blowing other peoples issues way out of proportion, DBR's avoid any criticism of their own and honestly, let's face it. It's major. I'm all for confidence but having a big head is not the same thing.

Darknlovely12 119 pts

If the myth of superior black athleticism goes out the window, then what will be left to maintain the black male mystique?

I think that EVERYONE is thinking the same thing. I hope that more Asian and White men become better at basketball, baseball and football and begin to dominate. I would absolutely love it!

mskallyj 35 pts

I dont know why people think this myth is true the only sports bm dominate is basketball, and football all other sports is mostly non bm.

AJ2011 2310 pts

This guy's smile is amazing. I know the post isn't about that but he is real easy on the eyes.

Ricky T 481 pts

AJ2011 LMAO, my gf thinks he is great! but he's NOT easy on the eyes. She calls him FUGLIN. lol *shakes head* she's so vain.

Law Wanxi 5805 pts

My last post on the topic.

Here's what non-basketball fans who don't care about Lin read about in the news.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/20/us-usa-accounting-idUSTRE81J0UL20120220

Monumental change unreported in the USA news. Takeaway is don't come crying to me when your US based 401(k) tanks. I will take a short on it and I'll be burning the 10's to make room for the 100's. I may take up cigars, just to light them with Jacksons.

Foreign news sites are your friend. Just Say No to sports and celebrity news. That crap is a luxury you can no longer afford.

Brice Cameron 2073 pts

What action are you taking in light of this news? It seems to me that global accounting standards would be a good thing. The U.S., being the worlds largest single nation economy (still), will of course have a huge say in how the rules are written. If we don't, I doubt we will adopt them. Do you think that global accounting standards will hurt the U.S. because U.S. companies are cooking the books? I would think that smaller countries would have a bigger problem with it.

Law Wanxi 5805 pts

Brice Cameron

US stocks will come under the GAAP of the IASB and will not be able to hide so much crap in off-shore operations consisting of a post-office box in Grand Cayman.

Brice Cameron 2073 pts

I am sure that the large U.S. corporations will not allow any standards to be adopted that harm their interests. They pay thousands of accountants to follow these developments and thousands of lobbyists to ensure they get thieir way.

ElfeV 7093 pts

Law Wanxi "Foreign news sites are your friend. Just Say No to sports and celebrity news. That crap is a luxury you can no longer afford."

I don't want you to be right, but you are right W. le sigh

This comment has been deleted
Law Wanxi 5805 pts

Rosie S In English; maybe if I'd had a Russian girlfriend.......

Here's a partial

http://www.reuters.com/

http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/index.htm

http://www.aljazeera.com/

and oddly enough, http://www.voanews.com/english/news/

http://www.guardiannews.com/

http://www.csmonitor.com/

candielady357 95 pts

Black male athleticism challenged?! Oh the horror! I really hope that happens, because perhaps black boys will start picking up books instead of balls and hitting the library instead of fields and courts. What an ironic twist to the stereotypes that would be!

ForeverCautious80 40 pts

candielady357 Thank you! I think the fact that Lin's presence is seen as some sort of attack on "black male athleticism" is a sad commentary. And really? To be fighting over athletic prowess? How shallow are his detractors?

Like you said, I hope it is challenged....if only to permanently kill the stereotype of black men being blessed athletically and nothing more.

SirLoinDeBeef 2526 pts

candielady357 Back in the 50s, when I was a kid/teen, there were NO black athletes on a college or national scale - that's changed, and now there are a majority of black athletes, to the point of it being commonly said that WM just can't run, throw, jump, pass or even compete with black men - now here's a bit of competition, and listen to the whine and bellyache!

Even better may be the influx of guys from Eastern Europe - strong, blonde people 200 cm (6' 6") and over there are pretty common ... and they can pass ball pretty well.

Jamila 7250 pts moderator

SirLoinDeBeefcandielady357 The craziest part of the whole "black people are naturally athletic" tripe is that, from what I've seen, white people are more likely to be athletic than black people, and I'm not talking about being more genetically inclined to athleticism, but just due to socioeconomic factors white people grow up taking part in a much wider variety of sports and other athletic activities than black people.

For poor black kids, it's basically basketball and football and track. Middle class kids (black, white, Asian) are growing up playing tennis, swimming, baseball, wrestling, hockey, etc.,

Patricia Kayden 1673 pts

I don't think one Asian male doing well in basketball is a big threat to the myth of Black male athetic superiority. Good for Lin for playing some good b-ball though. Hopefully, he won't follow the many former Black athletes who are now living below the poverty line after wasting millions of $$$ doing God only knows what.

Brice Cameron 2073 pts

You missed the most typical response. Jason Whitlock, a black male sports writer, did a twitter post about LIn referring to the other stereotype favorable to Black males in comparison to Asian males. It was deleted and I won't repeat it, but you can find it easily.

Jamila 7250 pts moderator

Brice Cameron I saw Whitlock's comments too but I decided not to include it. I linked to an article in this post where another black guy breaks down all the dumb stuff that black men have been saying about Lin.

Brice Cameron 2073 pts

I guess I should have read the link. I see it is in there.

Jamila 7250 pts moderator

Brice Cameron No problem, the info was easy to miss.

Mikimi101 6 pts

People, I'm surprised that you didn't make a post about the relationship between Asians and blacks within this post. After that idiot Floyd posted on twitter his racist views, an Asian - American girl(Jenny hyun) started going on a racist rage against all black people wanting to exterminate us all, I think that should have been included.

Toni_M 18891 pts

Mikimi101 Actually, I get what you're saying. Still two wrongs DON'T make a right, and it would be off topic.

It's always amazing to me though how many people think that the best way to respond to hatred and racism is WITH hatred and racism. :/

Mikimi101 6 pts

Toni_M I agree, and I'm really torn because I'm a fan of K-pop and time and time again there is always something that makes me think why the heck do I still listen to this music?!.
I think it would be nice to have a post about the relationship because thingies things REALLY need to be talked about.

Toni_M 18891 pts

Mikimi101 I imagine Korean fans of hip hop felt the same way despite the west coast rift between the African American and Korean American communities.

I'm gonna like what I want and I'm not going to have my hobbies barred by some idiots.

As for Hyun, I'm sincerely convinced she's mentally ill. I think she was talking about schizophrenia at one point, and the tone of her tweets and blogs suggests as much. I don't think that excuses her racism at all, but as I'm convinced she is in serious need of medical attention, I just feel sorry for her.

Mikimi101 6 pts

Toni_M True :( I heard she was sent to the hospital for this this morning and people know where she livworried actually worried for her. But yeah, I still like it no matter what :)

ForeverCautious80 40 pts

Toni_MMikimi101 That's pretty much how I feel, which is why I have avoided commenting on the matter, for the most part. For some strange reason, I can't muster up any energy to feel angry with her (even though what she said was beyond vile). I pity her.

blackwomanalive 373 pts

Mikimi101Toni_M This is something that has always baffled me. I just don't understand what kind of relationship we are supposed to have. I mean, are we supposed to learn Korean and they have to take a Black history course? I mean, you can only relate to people as individuals anyway. *shrugs*

introvertedwanderer 1056 pts

Toni_MMikimi101 I think that a lot of times it's because they had those feelings anyway, so when someone does/says something wrong/offensive, it gives others an excuse to say exactly what they have been wanting to say. I didn't read her rant, but I heard about how awful it was.

introvertedwanderer 1056 pts

Toni_MMikimi101 You ever read news articles and then read the comments afterwards. If it involves a minority, and especially if it involves black people, people who have been wanting to say something racist, come out of the woodwork to do so. Same thing on other platforms such as YouTube, etc.

Brice Cameron 2073 pts

introvertedwandererToni_MMikimi101

When I read youtube or other similar comment boards, I wonder if there are that many closet racists out there or there are just a few who are extremely busy commenting on multiple websites.

Toni_M 18891 pts

Brice CameronintrovertedwandererMikimi101 I blame the internet disinhibition phenomenon: More people feel comfortable saying stupid things when typing largely anonymously than they do in real life. Give the same persons a microphone and put them on television where everyone will know who they are and what they think...not a peep. I'm convinced.

There are a lot of stupid people out there we'd be otherwise unaware of; it's just that the internet now offers more idiots than ever the opportunity to say ridiculous hurtful things and not have to own it.

introvertedwanderer 1056 pts

Brice CameronToni_MMikimi101 ` I really do think that there are that many of them out there. Yeah, there also just the trolls who go onto message boards and try to stir up arguments, but other than that, I do believe that a lot of people feel exactly what they express in their comments. But like Toni said, they wouldn't have the nerve to say it other than on an anonymous message board/forum.

I've gone on to Stormfront, just to see exactly what some of these people think, and a lot of the people who post on there, are just your average, everyday jane and joe that you'd encounter at the grocery store and post office. That's why you can never really know what people are thinking, because a lot of them encounter people of other races on a daily basis and would not say anything offensive to them, but they most definitely feel superior and have a lot of negative, nasty assumptions.

Brenda55 19605 pts moderator

Brice CameronintrovertedwandererToni_MMikimi101

"When I read youtube or other similar comment boards, I wonder if there are that many closet racists out there or there are just a few who are extremely busy commenting on multiple websites"

IMO there are that many.

SirLoinDeBeef 2526 pts

Toni_MBrice CameronintrovertedwandererMikimi101 Americans think that they invented racism, with our recent-past culture of short-circuted slavery/feudalism, but it ain't so ... for and extreme degree of government-approved & institutionalized racism, you have only to look at North Korea.

Dr. Law, if I've offended, I apologize ... but I did order The Cleanest Race to my Kindle 2 nights ago, at your suggestion that I read here.

Law Wanxi 5805 pts

SirLoinDeBeefToni_MBrice CameronintrovertedwandererMikimi101

Typical White guy; that book is free from your public library, LOL!

It's a good and informative read that explains why we get so much wrong about the Norks.

SirLoinDeBeef 2526 pts

Law WanxiToni_MBrice CameronintrovertedwandererMikimi101 Yeah, but the Kindle goes with me on the cruise and the library book doesn't.

blackwomanalive 373 pts

Mikimi101 I got a message from her and I don't even know how she got my Twitter. It was like literally the same day I signed up for Twitter and already there was drama. I did read through her Tweets and it was....disturbing. I just asked her not to contact me again and leave me alone. I don't know who Floyd is or what that situation was.

Law Wanxi 5805 pts

Mikimi101

I had to look her up. Let's see, Jenny [I bet that comes from Jin] Hyun [at least it's not Kim] is a US-born songwriter... OK, that's enough, don't need to read any more. She looks OK, has that look that White guys like, according to what I see on Google Images. Songwriter, not doing anything to benefit society. Bias probably comes from too many shared alleles with too many inner-city store owners. Well, if you don't like the neighbourhood, open a store somewhere else. Montana and Wyoming need mini-marts, too, ya know.

Here's this doctor's prescription for little Hyun Jin, and yes, I will go there and I will say that. If she wants racial purity she can achieve that with a one-way ticket to Korea. Specifically, North Korea, home of "The Cleanest Race In The World". Maybe she can score a lovely little pied-à-terre in Pyongyang [which I pronounce ping-yang with a smile like they do in Beijing] and live a happy, Black People Free life writing songs to praise the Young General or whatever they're calling Kim Jong-Un this week.

That will shut her up for a while; hopefully a long while.