Serena Williams Caricatured By a White ‘Friend.’ Was Her Response Appropriate?

Serena Williams Caricatured By a White ‘Friend.’ Was Her Response Appropriate?

Was Caroline Wozniacki being racist when impersonating Serena Williams? How should Williams have responded?

Author : Jenn M. Jackson

Author's Website | Articles from

A few weeks ago, A well-known Danish tennis player named Caroline Wozniacki drew a lot of attention for her rendition of Serena Williams’ physique and demeanor. To be sure the audience knew exactly who she was emulating, Wozniacki stuffed her top and skirt with padding and towels. Her normally petite frame was a padded mess of bulbous humor as she grunted and groaned for an entire round of tennis. Some have spoken out about this behavior noting that it was racist and an overt stereotyping of black women’s physical features. But, were these reactions overblown? Was Wozniacki simply poking fun at her friend in jest?

Williams herself had remained relatively quiet about this issue up until recently. In an email to USA Today last week, Williams seemed unaffected by the impersonation.

“I know Caro and I would call her my friend and I don’t think she (meant) anything racist by it.”

From this response, it appears that Williams would rather move past it than wallow in what she deems a petty and irrelevant joke. She noted, in the same email, that other tennis players had done similar things but were not labeled ‘racist.’ So, she could not understand why Wozniacki’s behavior was judged so harshly. But, the world recognized tennis player did say that Wozniacki may want to forgo the caricature next time.

“I must add if people feel this way she should take reason and do something different next time.”

As a black woman, I will admit, I found the visual parading of Wozniacki in front of a predominantly white male audience extremely offensive. It reminded me of a minstrel show more than anything else. To think that a woman as beautiful and accomplished as Serena Williams could be made fun of on such a large stage (with no recourse mind you) is truly astounding. Additionally, the nature of the joke hits an especially sensitive chord with many in the black community. The magnitude of discrimination that black women have faced over the years because of our physiques is innumerable. But, to have an audience chuckle as a white woman mocked a black female celebrity of Williams’ caliber was seen, at least in the black community, as one hundred percent racist.

We are all familiar with the stereotype of the Jezebel. And, Wozniacki’s behavior harkened back to this illusory symbol of the black female image. But, the Dane probably had little knowledge of this American creation since she has likely had little access to black American culture or American culture in general.

Some have noted that the lack of consequence for Wozniacki’s ‘impression’ of Williams seemed lopsided. This summer, Williams received harsh criticism for ‘crip walking’ after she won Olympic gold at Wimbledon. The dance was highlighted as “gang-related” and “popularized by gang members.” This occurred even though folks all over the world have been doing the dance for many years. And, Williams is from Compton, the city where the dance basically started. Williams has no history of gang violence and loves to dance. But, her decision to do so after the conclusion of one of the greatest tennis matches of her lifetime was met with immediate disapproval.

Many have simply shrugged off Wozniaki’s antics without a second thought. Even though her behavior was highly offensive to many in the black community, she offered no apologies or explanations. And, it seems Williams was fine with that. On the other hand, Williams herself has been the target of racialized epithets in other settings. She has been brought to the fore on her perceived lack of sportsman-like conduct. But, when others have targetted her, she has done little to disabuse them of their stances. Should she have said something in this case? What was the appropriate response?

Be Sociable! Share!
Pinterest


Related Posts


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Itsmeagainisntit 5 pts

Why on earth should anyone regard this as racist? Wozniak was simply poking gentle fun at a fellow tennis player who happens to have big breasts and a big bum (and is beautiful too).  She wasn't poking fun at Williams for being black. Some white women have big breasts and big bums.

jakethewrestler 402 pts

It was done to Serena who is a beautiful strong, smart and sweet lady.  It was a joke and to me a compliment. A compliment becasue she does have dominate features and a compliment because she has a great sense of humor.  God Bless Serena.  Serena gives the most real and entertaining interviews of any sports athlete.  She has done a lot for the sport of tennis and I the people who really care about the sport  have great respect for her.  THIS IS JUST ONE MORE SIGN THAT WE NEED TO APPRECIATE HER MORE 

Asia 195 pts

I was very upset when I learned of Serena's crip walk after winning. Anywho she just needs to kick her butt if they ever get a chance to play against one another.

jakethewrestler 402 pts

why?  she Serena is a treause? sweet? gives great interviews, loosens people up, has thick skin I love her and appreciate her.  People said bad things about Muhamood ali and he became the most loved athlete in the world ever

Asia 195 pts

 jakethewrestler I feel like there were a ton of other much more positive dances and actions she could had done upon winning. Why she choose to promote that kind of behavior, I don't understand.

jakethewrestler 402 pts

All we ever see is the tennis pros displaying mythical sportsmanship. we hardly get the see the kids inside them.  I alwasy loved the silliness of  Serena interviews with John Macenroe and now I  love Caroline and everyone else that makes me laugh

DeepWater 2464 pts

Finally, I got through.    Hope Serena wipes the floor up with this chick, she ain't nobody, and most likely, never will be.  Homie, Serena, took the high road.   No way I would have done that.....tennis is a white sport, unfortunattely, still.   Serena will do her talkin' on the court and will wipe it up with this sad excuse for a jokester.   Bwaaahhahahahaha.    I think what this chick has done is nasty remeniscent of Hottenot Venuse, hating on Serenas's God-dess status, she's jealous, and hateful.   I'd, if I were Serena, wipe the floor up with this chile....word.

ieishah 779 pts

Far as I'm concerned, the only appropriate response would be for Serena to whoop that Dane like she stole something the next time they meet on the tennis court. And by "whoop", I mean, "win handily". 

Blanc2 345 pts

It is a normal part of exhibition matches for tennis stars to make fun of other tennis stars, and do other funny things, to endear themselves to the audience.  The audiences have come to expect this.  It makes the stars seem more human.  It's part of what makes these events entertaining.  It sells tickets.  Novak Djokovic is especially famous for his lampoon impersonations of Nadal (exaggerated picking of his wedgie -- to the extent that Nadal has gotten angry about it in the past), Federer, etc.  It's all done in good fun to entertain fans.  Hence his nickname, "The Joker".

 

Serena and Wozniaki are known to be friends and I do believe that Wozniaki's personal subjective intent was that she was acting in this same spirit of fun.  Serena's response is consistent with this.  In fact, Wozniaki has impersonated Serena in a similar fashion on prior occasionis without any hue and cry.  Her Serena act has become a staple for her at exhibition matches.  She isn't saying or doing anything that expressly says she believes Serena is ugly.  In fact, my guess is that Wozniaki, who has a figure like a carboard box, is probably envious of Serena's ample femininity.

 

Further, it's not like this issue comes from a vacuum.  Serena herself has been known to wear outfits that intentionally showcase her BOOM! POW! curves, both on and off the court, and she has commented on them in the press.  In other words, the fact of Serena's generous womanly form has been made a public issue in part by Serena herself.

 

But (and here is where I agree with Lady A, below)

 

There is a dynamic that most commenters have missed, and it has to do with social power.  It's bigger than just Caroline Wozniaki and Serena Williams, and it's bigger than white women and black women.  For example, it's not uncommon for the male tennis stars to dress in drag -- tennis dresses, wigs, etc., -- and feign "female" styles of playing, to the guffaws of the audience.  See how silly women look trying to play tennis.  Haw haw.

 

You don't see the women dressing in "male" drag and impersonating the men.  The distinction is that, whereas much of the exhibition match fun-poking is related in some way to the manner of playing or other actions of the person being lampooned, when the guys dress in drag, they are making fun of immutable physical characteristics of the women as women.  It may not be conscious on their part, but it is in a very real sense a display of perceived heirarchy or power of men over women.  It reinforces the notion that it's okay to put down women.

 

In the same way, the white woman making fun of Serena's physical body comes from that same energy, making fun of an immutable physical characteristic rather than something about her tennis game.  For the guys:  "Let's laugh at girls."  For the white girls:  "Let's laugh at the black girls."

 

Serena has done her share of poking fun at other players during exhibition matches, including making fun of her own sister.  However, I'm quite certain we will never see Serena create a costume out of a box (which is a rough approximation of Wozniaki's figure) and try to pass it off as a Wozniaki impersonation.  Most would regard it as mean-spirited even if it was just one friend japing another.  Society generally accepts it when a "higher" social caste lampoons a "lower" social caste.  It is this ready acceptance by the public of this genre of pecking order reinforcement that troubles me.

 

 

 

JennMJack 1180 pts

 Blanc2 So, while I agree that exhibitions have been historically riddled with shenanigans and Wozniacki and Serena are friends, that doesn't change the messaging or the mockery. I have not previously seen other tennis stars spend this much time getting themselves together during a match and then playing a few volleys in character but I don't watch tennis religiously.

 

It reminds be of a quote from Martin Luther King, Jr.

 

“In the end, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends.”

 

When I saw this and saw that Wozniacki did not make a statement to say that she and Serena are friends and she does not hold any racial animus toward her, it concerned me. If indeed it was a simple joke and there was no malicious intent (whether consciously or subconsciously) I think she could have addressed the concerns in a mature way. Again, this was a teachable moment. And since neither Serena nor Caro saw it that way, the media was able to write the narrative. That was where the real issue emerged in my honest opinion.

It's not the fact that they were friends or Serena's response it's about how "SOCIETY" viewed it. People laughed NO MATTER if the intentions were harmless or not people "LAUGHED". This proves to the rest of the world black women are allowed to be mocked, bashed, approached with bias, stereotypes and everything in between then no one cares NOT EVEN OTHER BLACK WOMEN. It's about respect and seeing people just as uncomfortable and outraged as they would be if it were reversed. Remember the youtube trend videos the "Things people say" and the black girl made the video "Things white girls say to black girls" white women got upset and white people in general and considered it racist because she was just making a "harmless" video about how white people sometimes approach black people about certain subjects. The sista even had to go on television on Dr. Drew I believe and address it. And lets not forget the RGIII incident even though he was targeted by another "black man" as himself people felt it was racist of the other black man to say how he's not black enough or married IR, society found it insulting, imagine if a white analyst said it, they'd probably create a new law about it.

 

But when black women are ridiculed doesn't matter if the person is foreign, American, black, white, male or female PEOPLE SHRUG IT OFF, LIKE NO BIG DEAL. And it's annoying when black women shrug it off as well. We have to let go of this "Strong black woman" attitude reaction because in some instances it's not helping us especially when we're globally stereotyped and made fun of like no big deal. It's 2013, if things were no big deal stuff like this still wouldn't make headlines meaning people still see it as an issue. Serena was pictured out on a boat with her boo and I seen comment calling her a "gorilla" age old racial names.

 

Black women we can't operate in society without being under a microscope moreso than others. Everyhting we do, others can do and won't recieve the same level of backlash because according to some people on youtube black women have little margin for error. We are unfortunately by the fault of DNA, damn you DNA, black and female so we have several sections of stereotypes, judgements and labels we have to endure.

 

It's not about anything it's about how black women are universally seen and respected, we're the least defend and respected group on the planet but society jumps at the dot when other groups are disrespected. We need to start being like our gay brothas and sistas, they even had NBA making commercials about being targeted and seen as joke, why can't black women do the same? How come we accepted this kind of treatment. It annoys me greatly and irritates the hell out of me. Sorry had to rant.

Also we can't just excuse it because she's foreign and assumed to not know about race relations in America. On several occasions foreign soccer fans threw bananas at black soccer players, and a Spain basketball team was placed on the hotseat for pulling their eyes back making fun of Chinese people during the 2008 Beijing olympics right? People called them all kinds of racist and ignorant, and guess what they said? The same thing some others were saying "Oh it's just harmless it's just a joke". So I'm probably "SURE" racial issues, stereotypes and other things are known globally, and I'm also sure people know how sensitive these topics are judging by the response to those incidents. If a guy ties his shirt up and twirls around and snaps his finger and gays find it stereotypical and defensive then create outrage would we say "maybe they don't know about the history of the gay rights movement in America" no because like racial issues homosexual rights is a global issue and people know it's a sensitive topic. Racial history, wars, and other things exist all throughout or country which enables other countries to develop their perceptions about other groups. Asian women got upset about the vogue issue and how they were depicted in the magazine and something was done about it. No one told them "It's just fashion". Black women were mimicked as well in the vogue spread, some black women complained but guess what happened? Many people including other black women said "Oh it's not that bad, I don't find it racist". It's just amazing to me how nonchalant people are when it comes to the mocking, stereotyping and generalizing to black women, and that's why we're still viewed the way we are according to that study about white men and BW relationships.

Morenika 842 pts

I think the friend maybe jealous of Serena.  Why else would she go to this extreme to try and humiliate Serena and it did not work. Ha Ha.

dani-BBW 1787 pts

How unprofessional. I'm curious as to what standards the international governing body of tennis has regarding on court conduct. Would it be okay to imitate, even in jest or love, someone who has a bit of a limp from some type of personal childhood tragedy? Or a big nose if they are jewish? Would it be funny if a british player mocked the player from Spain, can't recall his name, and pretended to curse in broken Spanish?

 

I also don't see it as a race issue since the woman is Danish but it was not in good taste, even if innocently intended.

GetMeOutofBlackistan 297 pts

The statement about Serena receiving undue criticism for her crip walk is not entirely fair. While Serena has not been affiliated with any gang activity, gang violence has touched her family -- her sister was murdered by a member of the Crips gang. That was the reason some (including many black people) were outraged by it.

zipporah 1730 pts

What she did was trashy, like most modern 'entertainment'.  I also  believe many blacks dont care what the modern 'black community' thinks when many of them are, or close to, 'blackistans'. I feel bad though for black girls/women who dont see anyway out of  the stereotypes. Many that are prepetrated by black men and white women (they know its slim pickins of any age with men) BTW what happened to that 'pure vanilla' troll anyway?.

Lexi88 2193 pts

Kudos to Serena for brushing this off. Malicious or not, Serena's response showed Wozniacki and the world that she will not allow anyone to affect how she feels about herself. 

My only gripe is the effect this will have on young black girls. It seems no matter our many accomplishments, our features and physical make-up will always be the bud of everyone's jokes. 

Would this "joke" be acceptable if a black man was behind it? Or would he be seen as another brother "hating on us"?

What if Serena decide to "joke" about Muslims, or Jews...would they brush it off? Would anyone brush it off as her having a good laugh?

I'm pretty sure this is not the first time Serena has had to deal with this kind of "joke" and I'm pretty sure it won't be the last. We are just too sensitive, always making too much out of everything.... I'm pretty sure other athletes deal with this kind of teasing on a regular basis. Maybe next time Wozniacki could paint her face black, wear a larger nose and weave down to her back.... It would be hilarious! 

 

JennMJack 1180 pts

 Lexi88 Great points! She did handle it well but I know that had she done something similar, she'd be vilified, ostracized, maybe even fined. So, the 'joke' really does underscore some harsh realities for the tennis star.

This comment has been deleted

Not when black women have been ridiculed and alienated for centuries because of our hair, skin color, bodies, and facial features, and then they go out buy or features and get praised for them "IT'S NOT COOL". It's like telling black women we took the cookies you made, put our name on it and sold it.

Seenyc 786 pts

I first heard about this story on The View around Thanksgiving. My first thought was of Sara Baartman.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQ7mmMe4klQ

 

Seems no matter the level of success of a black women, they should have to endure ridicule even from people who claim to be a friend.

Seenyc 786 pts

I will give Wozniaki the benefit of the doubt because she has no direct  exerience of  the history of slavery and it's vestigaes here in america, but she is suspect in my view for doing that in such a public arena. I allow peole to claim only so much ingnorance as the internet has a wealth of information availble to anyone at anytime in many languages.

JennMJack 1180 pts

 Seenyc I think that is one part of the post that no one is getting at. Why did she have to do it during a match at exhibition? Literally everyone was watching. This wasn't during practice or during a pre-game scrimmage. She was literally in the middle of a match. And, it went on for an entire round...so, I get the joke but at the same time, there's a point where it just becomes extremely rude and inappropriate.

AshleyFisher 390 pts

Ok if your friend has assets and you're flat as a board how is that racist? If she was white would it be racist? I mean if Serena still had a big butt and breast as a white girl. Seriously it was just an exaggeration of her noticeably larger assets. I don't see it as racist as all. 

Dandelion100 585 pts

 AshleyFisher Agreed. People seem to equate large butt and breasts with black women. Those are not features exclusive only to black women, as women of all ethnicities have them. I would call this stunt tasteless but not racist. 

zipporah 1730 pts

large breasts and butt? dont many white women WANT THAT? LOL

MamieMooney 167 pts

B@Dandelion100 @AshleyFisher black women while not the only Women with these features have been historically scapegoated and discriminated against and even exploited due to these features I think that's the source of the offense thus the racist accusation .

 Dandelion100  AshleyFisher Large butts and boobs have been something that ethnic communities of color embraced opposed to whites, specificially black women, it's even scientifically supported. Even back then if you google Sarah Baartman a black woman who was abused, prostituted and treated like a freak show because of her body, it takes people back. Knowing how to sing in a soulful voice isn't a black person thing either since there's plenty of ethnicities of color who have golden voices but that doesn't take away from the fact that it started within the black race.

This comment has been deleted
AminahMatthews 542 pts

 ann4950

 

Yea, WHAT NERVE!

 

 I thought Martina Navratilova was born a man anyway...found out MUCH later that she was actually born ah fugly ass woman who happen to look like ah fugly as man.

 

These boyish/man looking women in Tennis have some nerve TRYING to mock the Williams Sisters. Its just plain jealousy. What could it be?

 

Venus & Serena, just continue whooping thier asses.

cocoababe 1580 pts

 AminahMatthews  ann4950 

" I thought Martina Navratilova was born a man anyway...found out MUCH later that she was actually born ah fugly ass woman who happen to look like ah fugly as man."

crying rn. LMAO

zipporah 1730 pts

dont you think these 'boyish women' were on steroids? lwouldnt put it past Martinas familiy to do that to her as a young girl.

Browncow 1441 pts

I don't think this young lady meant anything by it. I'm not offended. It only accentuated the fact that she has no boobs and no butt. She's also not from the USA so I'll give her the benefit of the doubt. If she were an American WW then, yes, I'd raise my eyebrow to her, but Wozniacki doesn't have that cultural reference.

JennMJack 1180 pts

 Browncow

 I agree. This is noted in the post. But, how do you juxtapose this against the criticism Williams faced for dancing after winning at Wimbledon?

Browncow 1441 pts

 JennMJack Unfortunately, the American public doesn't see outrage or insult in poking fun at BW. They do however see it in BW doing a crip walk after winning because they're looking for an excuse to criticize BW even when we're representing ourselves in a positive light. It's damned if you do, damned if you don't and BW are a very easy target because nobody is coming to save her or defend her honor. That's just my opinion. Americans are raging hypocrites.

greengirl7 330 pts

 Browncow  "they're looking for an excuse to criticize BW even when we're representing ourselves in a positive light."

 

It is because people have gotten used to seeing low and disgusting images of BW in the media.   [C]rappers have been telling the world that BW are trash and don't deserve any respect, for decades.   So some people watch BW waiting to see any sign of the "real BW" slip out, and they take any minor or imagined gaffe as proof that their mental picture of BW is accurate.

Browncow 1441 pts

 greengirl7 Ding ding ding!!! You just won the prize! :)

Statuesque 1749 pts

I'm sure Serena has dealt with these people and their behavior for years and has had to let it roll off her back. She knows full well that this idiot will be mentioned in the history of women's tennis only because she impersonated one of the GOAT. It's true that Europeans lack the direct experience with the minstrel show offensiveness, but I agree that there is a visceral negativity to a lot of the chatter and behavior directed at Serena and Venus from all sides. I don't think she should have addressed it differently. Personally, whooping upon that Danish non-entity should she earn the privilege of facing Serena on the court.

Statuesque 1749 pts

...is the best response of all.

JennMJack 1180 pts

 Statuesque

 I guess I somewhat agree. The two women are friends. And Wozniacki meant nothing by it (from what it seems). But, what about what the message meant to others who saw it? I think this was a teachable moment that no one capitalized on. And, more people should be willing to say "you may not mean this to do harm but sometimes, it still does."

 

It isn't about being PC. But, I just wonder how this sould have gone over if Williams were Jewish or Native American. What caricature would Wozniacki have used then? And would it be seen as purely in jest. I am pretty sure it wouldn't have been at all.

VintageNarcissa 3151 pts

I've been discussing this with other people online, and while I think it's admirable that Serena does not seem to think anything of it, there is just something about this that rubs be the wrong way. One, because the woman supposedly made a comment in response saying, 'Serena has been impersonating us for years,' or something to that affect. And two, this is not an isolated incited. I recently saw a video of Andy Roddick, I believe it was, doing the exact same thing, shoving towels down his shirt and pants and pretending to be Serena. I can't help but wonder if there isn't a hint of malice in these actions. I don't know if it's because tennis is one of these sports that does not get much press outside of it own circles unless the Williams sisters are involved, but you never hear about other tennis players doing things like this. Could it be that other tennis play's bodies are virtually unremarkable and indistinguishable from one another? I just can't see them being able to find such an obvious way to poke fun at another white tennis player. Personally, I see it no different when white women do underhanded things like say out loud to a black friend, 'is that your real hair?' I may seem like harmless mean girl fun to them, but the implications behind it are a lot more stringent. It basically implies that she is only known for her, assets, as opposed to her skill - when we all know that is far from the truth. In such sports, people don't tend to be well known outside of their own circle, unless the Olympics are going on (which I believer Serena cleaned up in as well). I mean the last white person to really make a buzz in the tennis world because of their looks was Anna Kornicova, and when was the last time we've heard about her? Mean while, the Williams sisters remain relevant over longevity, whether people are talking about their skill, or their relationships, or their diet (I absolute love that Serena is vegan!) The other side of me that is not offended by this is tickled at the fact that the only reason anyone main stream knows who this woman is, is because she attached herself to Serena, otherwise she would continue to be irrelevant outside of tennis circles. And she will fall right back int obscurity once this all blows over. But Serena will continue being a tennis champion, she will continue being relevant, probably until her very old age. She will probably be a Muhammad Ali of our time, that people still want to know what's going on with her long after she's retired and old and frail. So in that sense, this white girl's shenanigans don't really bother me that much. 

Toni_M 18952 pts moderator

 VintageNarcissa Yep. Serena will be in the history books decades, if not centuries from now. As for her detractors? No one will no or care who they are by that time for the most part.

Toni_M 18952 pts moderator

 VintageNarcissa know*

JennMJack 1180 pts

 VintageNarcissa

 I agree with the polarized perspective on this. On the one hand, it is a 'dust your shoulders off' moment. But, on the other, it underscores a disregard for the images of black women and probably could have been a teachable moment. So, I think that, though Williams handled with poise, the media might have done better to handle it with sensitivity and grace as opposed to a 'look at the racist white girl' experience.

VintageNarcissa 3151 pts

 JennMJack Yeah, I definitely have considered that this could also be a matter of, if this kind of of poking fun is common as such matches, leave it up to the media to report on this one instance and not any other. 

cocoababe 1580 pts

The chick in question deserves NO attention and that is EXACTLY how Serena handled the situation. She barely commented on it. It happened weeks ago and I honestly had forgotten about it.  I and many other people I'm sure had to google this woman to figure out who she even was or looked like. LOL that tells you everything.

 

"Even though her behavior was highly offensive to many in the black community, she offered no apologies or explanations. "

 

Worse, so many WORSE things are occurring in the black collective (there is no community) that get black women abused, robbed, raped, killed and related to this situation, ridiculed, that NO ONE, especially black Americans talk about, so sorry I don't want to hear about how offended a couple of black folks were about this incident.

 

We want to get our feelings hurt in situations like this but when it REALLY COUNTS... *crickets*.

When they start getting offended in huge numbers when black males publicly mock black women, then I'll take their outrage seriously.

 

I think Serena has handled this all very well.  She has grown up a lot since that blow out with the ref.  I do wonder if some of that has to do w/ the Frenchman she is seeing...