BWIP: Fantasia is the Reason for the (BWE) Season.

BWIP: Fantasia is the Reason for the (BWE) Season.

I guess if all you’ve ever had to eat is bat guano, it just starts to taste like chicken, right?

Be Sociable, Share!

Author : Christelyn Karazin

Author's Website | Articles from

I promised myself I wasn’t going to do this.  But I have realised that I’m simply not to be trusted with my own promises to myself, so I’m writing about every one’s favorite (fallen) American Idol star, Fantasia Barrino.  I mean, this poor woman, who just RECENTLY learned how to read, is a walking, talking cliche for how some of us black ladies feel so compelled to have some piece of a man and take what scraps we can get.

Exhibit A (I had to dust of some files to find this one:

You hear the part where the SOS Band lead singer keeps saying (?!!), people always talkin’ bout reputation? And then proceeds to say she doesn’t care what people say because, well, after dude has run around and poked the hoes—ehrm—I mean, the holes of as many women as HE wants, she’s got the fire ready with some Alize and a cheap swap-meet teddy waiting for that douche the come walking in at 3AM smelling of the Jessica Simpson perfume knockoff you can buy for 10 cents at CVS Pharmacy.

Fantasia recently had to admit that she NOT ONLY knew Mr. Just B. Goodtomie was MARRIED, but aborted his baby in August, which probably explained why she caught the crazies a few months ago and had to be hospitalized.

And you know the worst part about it?  [Some] Black women DESERVE this crap.  THAT IS, if ALL you want is a Negroidian man, knowing FULL WELL there ain’t enough of them to go around, and with the knowledge, resources, money and the newly-found comprehension of the English alphabet you STILL say color trumps character, then you get what you get and you don’t throw a fit.  Plain and simple: even with fame and fortune, Fantasia eschewed looking for the best man for the job and just settled for what was comfortable and familiar.  But I guess if all you’ve ever had to eat is bat guano, it just starts to taste like chicken, right?

Listen here, lurkers and BWE tender shoots: You elevate ANY man-I don’t care what color he is–to a level that you are willing to be the dog poop smear at the bottom of his Nike’s as he runs and stomps you further in and digs you out and dumps you in the trash, then you need a psychiatrist. THEN take two aspirin (or Vodka, whichever is handy) as visit Sojourner’s Passport, Acts of Faith Blog, Betty Chambers Has Spoken, and Interracial Dating Coach.

Be Sociable, Share!

Like this post? Share it!


Related Posts


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

^^^DatGurl! So true!!!! I feel sorry for Fantasia, I really do. We all make really bad choices. She just needs to find out who she really is and distance herself from people who use her and if that includes her family, then so be it. Keyshia Cole did it and it seems to have worked for her.

Grandmother always said: "Be VERY careful how you get a man, because you gonna lose him the same way."

It always slays me how women like this dont realize THIS MAN CHEATED ON HIS WIFEY/GURL/BABY MAMA TO DIG YOU OUT, so why do you think he wont cheat on and leave YOU???

And this dude works(ed) at T-MOBILE! 'Tasia is not that bright; at least pick a brotha who can bring the bread to the table like you!

Just to share other messed up people, this time hilarious:

1. This sistah and her 20 different mug shot with wigs and makeup on

http://www.dlisted.com/node/39841

2. Apparently 'Chinos' represents all Asian people....which prove my grandmother words: beauty fades, but stupidity is permanent:

http://www.dlisted.com/node/39839

I wonder if Fantasia is DBR. I loved her on American Idol and was elated when she won. I wish her nothing but the best, but it appears that she does not want the same.

When Whitney Houston married Bobby Brown, I was saddened that someone like her (who I looked up to and adored) would link herself to an obvious problem child -- and we all know how that worked out for Whitney.

Just hope that Fantasia is able to make a U-Turn before it's too late for her.

There was a made-for-TV movie on Lifetime about Fantasia (she played herself, Viola Davis played her mother, Loretta Devine played her grandmother, and Kadeem Hardison played her dad). Debbie Allen directed it (and had a cameo as one of the bad auditioners at an American Idol audition). The movie tried to make it seem as if Fantasia's life got better after winning American Idol, but it's obvious she's still got ways to go.

I never watched the reality show because 1) I don't have cable and 2) even if I did have cable, I wouldn't be interested. Whenever I see a celebrity with issues (like Fantasia, Lindsay Lohan, etc.), I always say "They need to stay out of the spotlight for a while and get their lives back on track!" I wish they'd heed that advice.

I feel for her little daughter. I just don't want her repeating this neverending cycle.

GS, that was the one I spoke about upthread, I saw it about a month or two ago so she was midst of this drama when it came on. I personally thought American Idol wasn't a dream come true, she seems to have even worse problems now. And you're right she has a daughter and it's great to hope she rises from the ashes like a Phoenix when she's 40 or 50 but her daughter don't have time for mommy to 'get it together' all that time and even if she does, that's great for her but the kid is screwed.

And you’re right she has a daughter and it’s great to hope she rises from the ashes like a Phoenix when she’s 40 or 50 but her daughter don’t have time for mommy to ‘get it together’ all that time and even if she does, that’s great for her but the kid is screwed.

I meant I hope the daughter doesn't grow up to repeat this cycle...I should've specified. Maybe Zion can grow up to be different than her mother, but it doesn't look like it's gonna happen if all she sees is this dysfunction and drama.

GS, I agree I'd hope that her child is not scarred by her bad decisions but most of the time the children don't get out unscathed. In all this Fantasia is going through, her child is watching and taking it all into her little spirit. SMH.

I am not really familiar with Fantasia or her life, as I do not watch that type of reality tv (Top Chef & Project Runway are the shows that I will watch, the rest is beneath me because it is garbage produced for the masses, like the gladiator events during the Roman empire).

A while back there was a discussion over at the blog Sojourner's Passport about the black community, where we discussed the division that has happened in the black community due to low breeding. I think that this is the case with Fantasia, and **many** others like her. When you have blacks who have "issues" breeding over several generations, each time breeding a product more inferior than the last, you are bound to get a product that actually doesn't know any better that what they are doing and actually lack the capability and williningness to do any better.

Back in the day, when blacks couldn't do any better, they ate substandard foods, like animal entrails and miscellaneous animal parts. Over the centuries, the substandard diets began to affect blacks on the cellular level to the point of disease creation (blacks are now more prone to high blood pressure & diabetes as a result of multi-generational poor diets).

Aside: ( One of my favorite celebu-chef's Anthony Bourdain was recently diagnosed with HBP and was told by his doctor to "lay off the pork". Do you think HE listened? Hard-headed, just like many blacks!)

Now with all of the scientific advancements, we know that there are many components of the "soul-food" diet that are harmful, yet we continue to eat it.

There was a recent report (I posted it on my FB page about a month ago and I wil try to look up the link for you) that was released that confirmed the fact that a chlid is what it's mother eats while she is pregnant. There was another recent report that was released that eluded to the fact that a child is what it's mother experiences while she is pregnant. With these two studies in mind, you should be able to understand that this damage is more than likely, irrepairable.

Irrepairable damage done by diet is the same as damage done by lifestyle and environment over multiple generations. Hood is as hood does and no matter how much money she has or resources she has access to, she will NOT get better, only worse, and her children will be no better off than she is.

This is multi-generational abuse and neglect and I am almost 100% sure that her offspring will turn out the same, as well.

The only thing we can do is make other's aware of the changes that they should make and we should NOT bring them into our circles until thay have made the necessary changes in their life that they need to make, otherwise we run the risk of them bringing us down, not us elevating them! IMHO

I think this is a well known fact - if the mom's pre-natal diet is poor, it will affect the baby's development. Also, formula fed babies do less well than babies who were breastfed. That's also why they tell pregnant mothers to seek advice on just about every single medicine before she takes it, even a headache pill, b/c of the potential impact it could have on the foetus. Mothers who are also substance abusers also give their child a poor start from jump. Their babies are born addicted to alcohol, crack, cocaine, heroine or nicotine - along with other birth defects, providing the baby actually survives in utero.

About black people having a predisposition to hypertension and diabetes because our bodies somehow mutated because of poor food intake, I don't know about that. I think that trend stands because of the continued high salt - high sugar diet of many people. Black people who eat healthy foods from jump don't have this problem. I think that's rooted in current dietary practices rather than in genetics. Gene related diseases arise as a result of a mutation that is passed down through the generations. Type II diabetes is far more common than the gene related type I diabetes.

Robynne, you're right I'm a type 1 diabetic. Type II is much more rampant b/c of bad diet which leads to obesity. But type II is preventable, I'm never really sure why people don't do the small things that would actually prevent it. Type I is genetic and from I know talking to my physician(s) over the years (31 years of diabetes LOL) things may happen that will make that genetic mutation arise and not stay sedate. My thought is that I got a bad flu at the age of 7 and it kick-started my genetic mutation. One of the reasons I try my best to keep my weight under control, it could cause severe complications for my diabetes, unmanaged stress does too. The mental and physical are hand in hand in health.

Type I runs in my mom's family as well, so I have to be careful with my sugar intake. Almost all my mom's sisters have it, save my mother and maybe an aunt or 2. It took my grandmother's life, and my uncle's life. In my uncle's case, it led to the onset of renal failure, and it went downhill from there. It's not something to play with...

No one in my family had it, at least in this generation but my guess someone probably had it previously it passed to me. Yea, it's so tough to deal with older people how have or people who develop when they are older. They are so set in their ways. I was so young, so I was easily moldable, so my family took all the classes and I went to diabetic camp every year. Everyone had to learn how to give a shot to themselves so they could give one to me, if need be. And my brothers know what to do if I have a hypoglacemic reaction. It changes your whole life and everything I do pretty much revolves around being a diabetic, it's always there. I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. I get upset when people who could prevent getting type II, just don't.

a friend of mine has DT1 and she said its unavoidable....hence why she is strict about her food choices. Genetics can mess you up truly....in my family high blood pressure and rheumatism is a reality. Hence, why my mom is always conscious about healthy living.

As strict as the diet is for type 1, it's 10 times stricter for type 2. If you have a good nutritionist/dietician they can certainly help you find way through the food maze, I just try my best to eat a balanced diet. But I can eat sugar, I just have adjust my insulin, only thing I can't do is drink sugary soda or juice. Most type 1 diabetics can have different ways their bodies react to carbohydrates and sugar. The diet for type 2 diabetics sucks and if they don't control it, they become insulin dependent. In many ways, I'm glad I have type 1 instead of type 2.

I believe the issue and discussion over 2 Khadija's blog was about the toxic environment and conditioning of African American, not about poverty per say or some 'low breeding' in the traditional sense. There are millions of poor and overworked people around the world from India to China, yet they do not suffer from the conditions that created a stagnated generations within the black community. Its about the weakest among us having children without any family structure, without fathers, without community unity.....which in turn results in the likes of Fantasia and many like her who continue the same cycle over and over again.

Quote: "Back in the day, when blacks couldn’t do any better, they ate substandard foods, like animal entrails and miscellaneous animal parts. Over the centuries, the substandard diets began to affect blacks on the cellular level to the point of disease creation (blacks are now more prone to high blood pressure & diabetes as a result of multi-generational poor diets)."

Hodan: I beg to disagree from a scientific perspective. Chinese people during the famine era, even to this day in certain Asian communities.....all they had access to was very sub standard food (mice, cockroaches, cats, dogs), yet it has never impacted their physical and mental functions. We black people whether here or in Africa do actually eat a lot more rich and heavy on substance food.....yet we all share the same disease profile with South Asians and Arabs. I believe it has more to do with high level cholesterol and glucose concentrated food that is costing us life. Its eating these processed food without leading a healthy life style.

Quote: "Irrepairable damage done by diet is the same as damage done by lifestyle and environment over multiple generations. Hood is as hood does and no matter how much money she has or resources she has access to, she will NOT get better, only worse, and her children will be no better off than she is. This is multi-generational abuse and neglect and I am almost 100% sure that her offspring will turn out the same, as well."

Hodan: I agree.

I don't know much about Fantasia because I do not watch her reality show or watched American Idol. However, you will know an emotionally damaged person by his/her behaviors. Women naturally struggle so much more with our self-esteem than men and if you added to that a very difficult life then it will result in a woman who will make wrong choices in the pursuit of finding something they lost: "LOVE" and "Security." Women will look for it in all the wrong places: a man or men, sex, having babies etc. However, the problem is, they will never be satified so the cycle continues. A person will not change until they hit their bottom or a brick wall and if she has not hit hers as yet then this behavior may continue to her destruction.
It may seem simple to the "normal" woman that she and other women are making bad choices but it is always fascinating to get into their thoughts and that will explain so much more about their distorted world view.

You're right she has issues, we all have issues. The best hope is that she actually comes to realize that b/c only SHE can do something about it. For most people, we don't do much introspection so we may not realize we're screwed up. That kind of dysfunction is probably normal to her and even the uncomfortable becomes comfortable when you do it long enough. She'll have to get to her bottom, whatever that is and hopefully she will do some self-reflection and get whatever she needs to be better and do better in her life. She can't do anything about anyone else, but she can do something about herself.

Just my 2 cents...

Aretha Franklin had an abortion at age 13. She was also robbed
blind of songwriting royalties by her Husband/Manager who
regularly put her in the hospital with violent beatings.

I don't think Fantasia is even 25 yet...so it's unfair to
compare her to Mary J. Blige (who was strung out on drugs at
Fannie's age). And of course, Patti LaBelle and Tina Turner
had similar life experiences before going on to become ultra
Iconic survivors with grace and savvy.

This news SEEMS fresh and new. But I have a strong feeling that
years from now we will be understanding WHY Fantasia had to go
through all of this in order to become an even more important
vocalist/artist than she is right now. These things either make
you or break you. And I have a feeling that Fantasia will rise
above all this in triumph similar to ARETHA, PATTI and TINA.

Just something to consider.

I hope so, out of all the women you mentioned, I rather see her follow the path of MJB who is happy and married. Aretha, Patti and Tina have all wasted their youth, talent and finance on utter losers and only in their 40s/50s did they wake up to a real revolutionary life changes. I know Tina has been with a French financier for 30 yrs now, Aretha and Patti keep their private life just that.

OMG Kola Boof! Beautifully said. Btw, I'm a HUGE follower of your work and loved your recent posts on Womanist Musings(Tyler Perry & How to Make Generations). Keep up the great work!

Fantasia is a hot mess that's for sure, but if you saw that biopic you'd see why. This didn't happen by accident, it was set-up to happen the way it did. That biopic wasn't exactly 'Citizen Kane' but even in there you could tell, that story was not going to have a HEA even the American Idol win. Winning some singing contest won't change all the damage that's been done to you over the years. Yes, she needs lots of interventions and help but in all likelihood she really doesn't think anything is wrong with her life. Watch what you wanna watch, not watching is not going to change her life, not watching may change yours though. But personally I think they need to show episodes of '16 and Pregnant' starting in middle school maybe sooner. Personally I stick with HGTV, the Food Network, Travel Channel and TCM. Yes, she is the young bw of today in some ways, man-sharing b/c that is now an 'option' when it comes to relationships. SMH. Being physically, emotionally, and fiancially drained by the BC (and I do mean her family) and that man. But you know what time passes quickly and we don't have time to waste. I feel like just yesterday I was 21 and now here I am almost 39, blink of an eye. It's precious and shouldn't be wasted but I see some older bw, who've wasted years in bad marriages, relationships, situations and now time is gone, never to come back again and all you have is regret. Yea there's a lesson here b/c Fantasia is getting older, the luster has worn off, people stop feeling sorry for you at some point when they figure out you're just stupid. One of the lessons should be don't waste your time, it's a gift, treat it like one b/c once it's gone it's never coming back, there are no do-overs. Let's hope she catches a clue, if not, let's hope some young bw catches a clue looking at her life.

You know I say that Hodan, b/c with most stuff on this blog I speak from personal experience. Those were my greatest lessons. I spent 12, 9 of them married to a man I shouldn't have been. We probably should have broke up a couple of months after we meet. But I did what a lot of women did, I sacrificed myself, I wanted it to work and I'm thankful I caught a clue and got out of there and found a wonderful man to share my life with but that's still 12 years of my life, gone. It's not a good feeling.

I might not directly relate, but I know what you mean. Evia over @ her blog always talks about how important it is for BW to take a good advantage of their youth and child bearing yrs (even if they have no intention to procreate) by seeking and marrying quality men who make them happy.

A friend of mine has been dating her guy for 7 yrs and now he proposed, but we don't think it will last. Their on-off union was never a stable one and she's often 2nd best for him.

Hodan, that is true. I learned a lot of lessons in that marriage, a lot about men, a lot about me, a lot about relationships but boy I wish I hadn't had to learn it the hard way. But I tell you what it's one I will never forget. :)
7 years before an engagement, pssshhh, sounds like manipulation is at work somewhere in there. Somebody doesn't want to be alone, so they do just enough to get you to stay then you stay and they go back to whatever drama they had in the first place.

you are still young and have a 2nd chance @ a happy union. I'm sure you have so much advice and wisdom to embark on your nieces and young girls on sites like these.

Thank you Hodan for those kind words. I'm hard on myself sometimes much harder than I am others. I realize I still some youth along with some maturity that's helpful in my new relationship and I'm thankful I do. And it's nice to have a second chance at a real, loving, fulfilling, supportive marriage. I'm just glad that it wasn't till my really late years that it happened. But it's nice to be able to actually live a real-life love story. And yes, all that wisdom I give over to my nieces and other young women I know that are willing to listen. I hope any women young or old, are able to take something from all of us. It's really brave of everyone to come on here and share.

This is kind of off topic, but WHY THE CUSS do celebrities take lewd pictures of themselves on camera phones? I mean REALLY. Eddie Long, Tiger...that guy Sandra Bullock was married to. GEESH!

because they are stupid and think anything you put on the net is safe. The queen of lewd pictures are all the disney chicks from Vanessa Hudgens to Miley Cyrus.

Here's my motto about stuff I put on the internet, stuff I say on my FB or whatever. If I can't put it on a billboard for the world to see then it shouldn't be on the internet. Because when you put it on here, in essence, that's what you're doing putting it on a billboard.

exactly and now employers and even school admins are looking and searching for FB accounts. The moment you put a picture of yourself out there, you lost the right to any legitimate privacy. In fact, facebook tells you its their bloody property.

Do you know all that stuff on FB and Twitter is stored at the Library of Congress? I friend I have whose an IP attorney told me about it after she learned that in an CLE. I'm real careful now. Hmm.

that's creepy, why would it be there if you are not an elected official? Then again with the passing of the Patriot Act, nothing is out of bound when it comes to electronic communication. Its a legislative power given to government, where all telecom. companies cooperate with them. Hence, why I always says there is no anonymity on the net unless you are a master hacker with multiple IPs, even then it will take less than 24 hrs to crack it.

Not to mention it's so low budget. You're a celebrity, you have money now! If I was going to take sexy pictures you best believe I'd be getting a professional photographer and an airbrushing team like you wouldn't believe. That way when it leaks (which it always does) at least I'd look damn good.

its simple: attention. ANY attention is good attention to celebrities. its doesn't matter if the things people say about them are good OR bad they'll just say/think, "well, at least i'm still being talked about..."

Hmmm...this thread is devolving into something else. I don't think the point of it was to rag on Fantasia (I think). I'm sure she's getting enough of that from the gossip blogs already. It's to be expected I guess, since she is an extreme case of bw damage. What people could do is stop watching this mess so that it gets canceled for want of ratings. Better yet, boycott the station that promotes this altogether. And, if you're really serious, write a nice note to the advertisers. It's BET part II, and I don't know how people watch these stations without knocking a few points off their IQ.

I agree about the boycotting. Heck I do it by default as I hate reality television universally. However, I think that you have to temper any pity for Fantasia with the simple fact that she, unlike 99.999999% of girls who have had her life, has resources. AND, WITH those resources, she can/could do better. She can AFFORD to seek help. At this point, it's a choice. She keeps making the wrong ones.

I agree, we shouldn't kick a person when they are down. Besides, this should be an example for everyone if they are not @ this state of self damage.....then make sure to advice and guide young impressionable BGs in your life so they don't continue this sick cycle.

About VH1, it all started with Flavor Flave, then 2 of the girls in his show were given a spot and the cycle of damaged beyond repair black caricature continues. In the words of Wanda Sype, we should've got rid of Flave long time ago.

Fantasia is such a hot mess! SMH! It's really sad that this is the same person who won American Idol all those years ago. She seemed like she had it together (for the most past), but that didn't happen. I truly believe that fame and fortune made her turn out even worse. Imo, that whole "suicide attempt" was planned to boost the ratings for her reality show and to help her album sales. I lost all respect for her after hearing that, plus all the non stop drama w/ her b/f who is a married man. Then on top of all that, she talked about having an abortion which she should have NEVER disclosed to the public. That is so private and such a controversial subject to even talk about. And to think that she couldn't get any lower. All of these reality shows like to focus on people's problems and make money off of it. T.V. is such garbage (VH1, MTV, BET, Bravo, and Oxygen are all the same.) I watched an episode and a half of Fantasia's reality show and I just couldn't watch anymore of it. Her family are a bunch of leeches (emotionally as well as financially) and Fantasia allows it. Of all people, Oprah even reached out to Fantasia not once, but twice! Oprah really wanted to help her out, but there's only so much you can do for someone who is deeply damaged like Fantasia is. Eventually, her b/f is going to drop her and then her money is going to dry up (she had money issues in the past already.) When she hits rock bottom, just MAYBE she'll decide to turn her life around.

I will NEVER agree that anyone deserves this, but until the individual stands up and says NO, nothing will change.

Someone mentioned her baby voice. I heard Dr. Drew(the addiction doctor) mentioned that when you here grown women talk with that baby voice it is usually a result of childhood sexual trauma. It's like they broke down emotionally at that point in their life and cannot move forward. He mentioned some famous women like Paris Hilton. It kind of makes since. But Fantasia and family are just a big ol dysfunctional family mess. I predict that she will do something else trifling in the future.

I watched her biopic not too long ago, the one she starred in, have no idea why just came on and I started watching. But in, she does get raped while in high school before she quit. It may have been that she was raped earlier and it was just too painful for her to act out in the storyline.

i don't think that's true at all; people talk the way they talk... childhood trauma (sexual or otherwise) really has nothing to do with a person's voice. c'mon, now...

SMDH...it's truly a shame. But what are you going to do? There has to come a time when women who have the same mindset and/or worldview like Fantasia decide that they want better for themsleves. Mary J did it and did it fabuously, one can actually see her growth and evolution as a woman. You HAVE to WANT better for yourself. If you don't no one will.

"You elevate ANY man-I don’t care what color he is–to a level that you are willing to be the dog poop smear at the bottom of his Nike’s as he runs and stomps you further in and digs you out and dumps you in the trash, then you need a psychiatrist."

Truer words ain't never been spoken.

I was about to go on a 50 page rant, but I just don't have it in me today. I just want to say 1)The fact she took that photo of herself and thought it was sexy just proves the state of mind she's in 2)I think she not only needs a professional therapist/psychiatrist and BWE blogs, she needs some type of spiritual guide. I knew/know women like her, and only a few actually saw the light. I hope she eventually realizes what destructive life she is leading, THINK of her freaking daughter and what type of example she is setting for her, and actually CHANGE her ways. 3) Can we talk about Alicia Keys, Gabrielle Union, and the other women in the Biz who have been man sharing? It's so sad that these women have let these trifling men to sink them down to their level.