“Fair & White?” Proof that Some Cosmetics Companies Just Don’t “Get” Black Women

“Fair & White?” Proof that Some Cosmetics Companies Just Don’t “Get” Black Women

This is not to be believed…

Author : Christelyn Karazin

Author's Website | Articles from

Because this blog is popular, I get a lot of pitches from various companies to hock this and that, and I’ll bet some of you think I just accept any old thing as long as it’s free.

Nuh uh. I turn down A LOT of people.

For instance, a publicist sent me a pitch for a line of skin care products and offered to send me review samples. While the formulations were intriguing, I just couldn’t get past the name and the marketing.

So White

Are they serious??

And yet another…

This is just too unbelievable. They ACTUALLY make sales with this marketing? “Hey darkies! Use our products so you can be FAIR AND WHITE, as opposed to DARK and UGLY!” What marketing director sat in their corner office and gave the go-ahead for this?

News flash skin-care makers: Black women DO NOT WANT to be told that the only way to beauty is by being “fair and white.” We have fought hundreds of years of oppression and colorism in order to embrace our unique beauty, and for you to suggest otherwise is not only offensive, it’s just plain stupid. The African American spending power in the U.S. will reach $1.1 TRILLION by 2015, and guess who’s gonna spend a big chunk of that money on makeup, hair, and beauty? You got it. BLACK WOMEN. It would serve manufacturers to do their research before they throw this steaming horse pucky our way. This ain’t the 1950′s, and even white folks don’t wanna be “fair and white” anymore, as evidenced by the wall-to-wall spray on tan products I see crowded the shelves to the local drug store.

Be Sociable! Share!
Pinterest


Related Posts


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
queenofnnewi 5 pts

I have worked for a skin treatment company for 2 years now. So I am speaking from experience. Asian's and Indians are number 1 in skin lightening followed by Africans.  African Americans mostly use it for corrective treatment acne dark marks like I had Chicken Pox marks, hyperpigmentation. It is suppose to be used to even out your skin tone. Many older women use our products for age spots.  Fair and White is the top seller among Africans from Africa in the America's and they are using it to bleach. They mix it with harsher creams because alone it can only change you back to the color you were born with which is lighter because we have not been exposed to the sun or harsh environment.

Corrector 5 pts

Why would you believe Fair and White or Dark & Ugly? Who said Dark is Ugly. Why not Dark&Lovely? really do not think you get the name Fair & White, please research. As for So White, the Product includes a leaflet, informing users that the name So White, derives from the fragrance, which is an extract of floral white tea, called So White...

Joyce345 1738 pts

LOL! The ad is so silly but there are sooooo many more just like this one it is pathetic.

This comment has been deleted
Toni_M 18714 pts

 Matrix12 Skin bleaching to the EXTREME is laughed at, but to say that American Americans don't and have never bleached is just not true. It's something that's not much talked about or admitted (especially post "black and proud" 70s), but BELIEVE me, it goes on. You can see it in Hollywood with certain actors (Eddie Murphy) using bleaching products to be lighter.

 

It has been in the news and on talk shows. Though I tend to side-eye the crap out of Tyra Banks, I do recall she did a show that sparked major controversy regarding very dark skinned women who were determined to become lighter. If you were to leave your computer and drive to the nearest beauty store or beauty department in a Walmart located near a large African American population, you would find "skin lightening" products.

 

Products like: http://is.gd/WZI99A 

 

The above I have seen in numerous stores in the "black beauty" section. THIS IS NOT A COINCIDENCE, and the products would not be placed there if  they weren't selling.

 

You may not be familiar with this, but trust this has been a long and existing issue in the African American community.

The Working Home Keeper 6554 pts

 Toni_M Matrix12 I came across a copy of Ebony magazine from the 60's online awhile back.  Quite a few advertisements for skin lightening creams!

 

ETA:  Found the magazine link

 

http://books.google.com/books?id=b9cDAAAAMBAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false

 

Toni_M 18714 pts

 Matrix12  The Working Home Keeper  "of course it happens, but like you said its not prevalent"

 

Define "prevalent". It's not TALKED about a lot, but those products continue to sell like hot cakes and have been for decades. You have to do the math: Products continue to sell over period of years = a lot of people are buying.

 

A problem in the black community is often not openly acknowledged, and even when it is, it's with the utmost reluctancy or a desire to not talk about it.

Toni_M 18714 pts

 The Working Home Keeper  Matrix12  LOL. Once upon a time they just told you the product was about lightening your skin, and the clearer complexion was treated as the bonus.

Toni_M 18714 pts

 Matrix12  The Working Home Keeper  In my mind, one woman or man feeling compelled to bleach their skin due to the pressures of colorism is too much, by the way. And colorism is yet another ugly subject that black people like to pretend does not exist, or isn't as big a problem as being made out.

 

I just think it's dangerous to dismiss a problem like skin bleaching among African Americans because everything I've seen of and know of the problem (yes, I know people who do this) indicates that no one knows exactly how big it is, but rely on discussion in the open and the tone of that discussion to determine how truly big it is.

 

But again, you've inspired me to write more articles and do more digging. :D

 

You're quickly becoming my muse, @Matrix12 ;D

Joyce345 1738 pts

 Toni_M  Matrix12  The Working Home Keeper  Matrix12 

 

I remember that Tyra show and to be honest I was really disappointed with the way the skin bleachers were treated.

 

A lot of the women using skin lightening creams on themselves and on their children have gone through a lot of trauma because of colorism.

 

We have to acknowledge the fact that these women are going through or have gone through some real trauma instead of just condemning them for what they do.

 

I have never bleached my skin but I know that if millions of women around the world are doing it - they can't ALL be complete idiots.

Toni_M 18714 pts

 Joyce345  Matrix12  The Working Home Keeper  I'm tired of black people acting like skin bleaching is a matter of people wanting to be lighter in order to be accepted by whites, or due to white racism.

 

African American colorism may have its roots in racism, but the ongoing hostilities aimed at people who are dark, especially black women, can no longer be blamed on white racism; the greater amount of emotional damage comes from the cruel way in which these people are treated by other African Americans.

 

I believe very strongly there is a connection between the success of color bleaching products in this country (success meaning that people buy them and therefore the market is profitable) and the desire to avoid being dark enough to be othered and stigmatized.

Toni_M 18714 pts

 Joyce345  Matrix12  The Working Home Keeper  I should say "success of skin bleaching products among black women in this country".

zipporah 1714 pts

Even though they have a black woman on the cover. I think the Eastern Indians have a worse problem wanting to be 'white' . Is there any dark Bollywood actors/actresses coming out of there? maybe, but I havent seen them. Plus many  use bleaching cream ...ugh

Bren82 1304 pts

I can't believe they had the audacity to propose such an ad.

grrlysquirrel75 1121 pts

@Bren82 Of course they did because they are operating under the misapprehension that all us black folks wanna be white.

kiki100 630 pts

OMG Is that Lil Kim I see with the straight nose and fair skin above? Damn the rumors were true. She actually did a photo op for Fair & White.? Wow.

I heard about Fair & White around 15 I think. My cousin was offended by the product. Even at a young age she knew what was up. Good job Cristelyn for turning them down.

grrlysquirrel75 1121 pts

@kiki100 That was my first thought, too! That totally looks like Lil Kim. How sad is that?

ann4950 732 pts

 kiki100

 LOL, are we to follow behind someone like Lil Kim?  I think NOT. 

ann4950 732 pts

I haven't read the comments yet. But, those products seems similiar to products sold in India. I believe the name is Fair and Lovely. LOL, become Fair and Lovely and all your problems goes away. Right? Then why some many other race women tan their skin? So much for fair and lovely.

Betty Boo 259 pts

You are right Chris, but as long as those who are in charge of marketing and promotions can keep black women believing  that black is not beautiful and the "ideal" is to be white or fair skinned. The dollars will keep rolling in. if it ain't broke why fix it??? This has been going on for a long time.

This comment has been deleted
ann4950 732 pts

 Pearl

 There are women in Africa using those types of products.  They have no idea what the chemicals can do to their skin. 

Robynne 300 pts

As islandgirl said, this company is not new. Their biggest market is in India, followed by east Asia. Surprise. I never saw their products in mainstream American stores. It's usually in "ethnic" (usually Asian) stores.

claireshegoes 41 pts

I'm stunned by this.  I know Chris wouldn't dare lie, but I couldn't take this Fair & White nonsense in until I saw their web site. 

 

And I'm still shocked.

nikichambers 137 pts

I'm inspired by this.  I should make a product line for the Jersey Shore wannabes.  I'd call it "Stupid & Orange".  I'm gonna be RICH!!!

Christelyn 8688 pts moderator

 nikichambers AHAHAHAHHAHAA!

Shulamit 1982 pts

 nikichambers bwahahahaah

Islandgirl 505 pts

These products have been around for years. These type of products have been scientifically proven to cause skin cancer and permanently disfigure users. In some countries there is a big drive to educate women about the dangers. Colourism is a huge factor why women of colour use these products but not the only factor. As someone mentioned before it took Coco Chanel to made possessing a natural tan popular because it is taken to mean the person is rich enough holiday in exotic places like Bora Bora. Previously and historically a tan was not desirable because it meant the person had to work in the fields. 

MySmile 4172 pts

wow..just wow..the funny thing is that on the website they keep saying it's for all races and skin tones...but all they have are brown/dark skinned black women in the pictures..hmmm.

Toni_M 18714 pts

I am just now picking my jaw off of the floor. Like....WOW. I don't think I want to know who else you've turned down as far as ads go. :S

oekmama 1047 pts

You know they wouldn't be selling it if they weren't making money  on it. Loads of women all around the world who believe that a lighter skin complexion will open doors to opportunities. Esp in the developing world. As more people get access to education and work their way out of poverty, this may change. I pray.

What I find hilarious is that they thought THIS site would be appropriate to market that junk. That's what gets me...

oekmama 1047 pts

What I wanna know Chris, is what did you tell em to do with themselves and the horse they rode in on? SMH +LMAO

Toni_M 18714 pts

 oekmama Maybe the title threw them somehow (?)

Zindzi_Zenani 1399 pts

I work at a cosmetics company (won't reveal the name, but you guys might figure it out) and our NUMBER ONE SKU is our skin bleaching creme.  Its ridiculously popular in the Caribbean, Africa, the UK and France.

 

Companies market this stuff because womben of color buy it.  Its ridiculously sad, but its true.  Some of our customers have been using it for decades...like, how light you tryna get?!?

 

Law Wanxi 5779 pts

From the parent company's website

 

"The Mitchell Group is headquartered in Miami and has offices in the United Kingdom. The Company distributes Fair & White, So White and the Yelen brands, all produced in France, while other brightening products from Mitchell Group are produced in the United States, Europe and Lebanon. The selling network extends to North America, South America, the Caribbean, the United Kingdom, Africa and Asia."

 

Ah, these guys; they've been around for years.  Big sellers that started out in the UK and came to the USA for tax reasons.  They've been big in India and the rest of Asia for, like, ever.  [gotta stick a 'like" in because I'm in SoCal...]

 

I know colorism sucks, but you're not going to change anything, because the target market is larger than just Black women.  A lot of people want this stuff and are willing to pay through there less than 'losa' noses for it.  'Losa' is a Pilipino term for porcelain white skin.  Hispanics also use the stuff.

 

As for the $1.1 * 10**9 in 2015, it sounds like a lot, but, according to Terry College of Business, U of GA, which cites a $1.2T for AfAm in 2015, the Hispanics will have $1.5T and Asians will have $775 Billion in 2015.  

 

Here ya go  http://www.terry.uga.edu/news/releases/2010/minority-buying-power-report.html  because you know I do love sourced stuff.

 

I look at the Mitchell products like I look at alcohol and tobacco and spectator sports.  I have no use for any of it, so I don't waste money on it.  Just look at it the same way and move on.  You have bigger things to worry about than Liyuan, Sushmita and Carlotta lightening their skin.  They use Black models because Blacks market well for beauty products for other darker women on the basis of 'if it works for them, it will work well for me'.  Same way the ED drugs are now all about Black guys with limp, uh, apparatus; sells well to Whites; removes the shame because even Black guys use it.  Mind control at its finest, employing the best people in consumer psychology.  

 

You have bigger fish to fry.

Shulamit 1982 pts

sh*t  Coco Chanel made tanning popular in the 1920s. Ima need them to come a bit forward. seriously? I am reposting this to my blog. seriously..

kennaGransberg 142 pts

and this is why so many black people bleach their skin in other to be fair and white because thats considered to be 'true beauty'. as one of my history lecturer said in college, you never here people say brown(browning is what jamaican call light skin people) and pretty. SMH!

Lejusdecoco 206 pts

Those products are all over the beauty  supply stores, there are so many of them. I know some black women uses them because when you see them on the street , their skin tone doesn't match; the face is another color while the rest of the body is something else. This is absurd!

Lejusdecoco 206 pts

Also they are  selling a great amount of these products to poorer countries to. In Haiti, these products are very common, and the larger population is buying them and bleaching their skin without questionning it.

dani-BBW 1784 pts

 Lejusdecoco You know, I've been wondering about that. I think that lightening agents are present in cosmetics/beauty products targeted toward women of color. Both my mom and I are 10 shades lighter then we were as kids, it's really weird and we've never used bleaching agents to lighten our complexions. I have an Ambi tube but I only use it for acne scars, I've never rubbed it all over my whole face.

 

I've heard Diana Ross' complexion has lightened up considerably - Kola Boof talks about it regularly - but I can't tell in pictures if it's the lighting or something else.

Lejusdecoco 206 pts

@dani-bbw, exactly  these products do contain lightening agents. Ambi is definitly one of them,   the list goes on and on. you know what , it usually states its for acne  scars but  I dont believe it all.  I remember using one of these products my face was getting lighter and the scars did not disappear. I ended up going to the dermatologist and I love it

Christelyn 8688 pts moderator

 Lejusdecoco I know that some women do have legitimate issues with discoloration, and I have no problem with them seeking products to reduce that. My main issue is the name, and what it implies.

MercedesHasLeftTheBuilding 1060 pts

fair and white.....W.T.F.? O__o. smells like another 'okey-doke" to me.

 

the only makeup that i use is Fashion Fair,Dermablend & Iman.

nikichambers 137 pts

What the hell? Does each product come with a blonde wig and blue contacts?  The sad part is that the name is going to appeal to some people and they are going to rush to buy it or promote it.  But we aren't all falling for that ish!!

divalocity 35 pts

Anything that plays on the insecurities of some women will always make a profit.

Christelyn 8688 pts moderator

 divalocity I'm sorry. No way would you see me standing in line with this stuff in my grocery basket. "Price check for Fair and White for the Black lady here!" :-/

Law Wanxi 5779 pts

 Christelyn   divalocity 

Leading quickly to 'Cleanup on Checkstand Three'. LOL!

divalocity 35 pts

 Christelyn  If you're not insecure in your own beauty then it is no problem for you, but you've been in this world long enough to know that there are a lot of women who have been conditioned to believe that they aren't beautiful just the way they are and will spend their hard earned money in an attempt to achieve the unattainable.

 

I've been defining my own beauty for five decades and proudly so. I believe that beauty has no boundaries and it saddens me that so many women don't believe they are beautiful just the way they were created.